5 Best Pizza Places in Indianapolis to Try

Indianapolis boasts a dynamic pizza landscape that marries tradition with creativity.

Whether you’re seeking thick Sicilian slices, thin Neapolitan perfection, or classic New York–style comfort, the city’s best pizzerias deliver something for every palate.

Here are the five pizza spots making the biggest impression on Indy locals and visitors alike.

1. Futuro

Widely regarded as Indy’s top pizza destination, Futuro specializes in Detroit-style pies with a thick, airy crust and caramelized cheesy edges.

They also offer classic round and thin crusts, letting diners choose their style. Signature combos and a robust build-your-own menu keep things exciting, with fresh ingredients and bold flavors anchoring every bite.

With a devoted local following, Futuro is a must-visit for pizza lovers craving something crave-worthy and unique.

2. Greek’s Pizzeria – Indianapolis

Greek’s has become a local staple thanks to its delectable, hand-tossed dough and gooey cheese baked to bubbly perfection.

Their menu is a mix of classic and creative pies, with plenty of options for meat-lovers, vegetarians, and everyone in between.

The Columbia Avenue location, in particular, shines with attentive service and a loyal fan base. The pepperoni and Greek’s Special are highly recommended.

3. Magoo’s California Pizza

Known for its fast, friendly service and inventive pizzas, Magoo’s California Pizza brings a West Coast twist to the Indy pizza scene.

Thin, crispy crusts, oversized slices, and premium toppings are the name of the game here.

Signature pies feature California-inspired combinations, alongside classics prepared with a fresh spin.

Magoo’s is perfect for a fast lunch or late-night snack, with loyal fans crowding in for a taste of something different.

4. I Tre Mori

If you want rustic Italian charm and a wine bar atmosphere along with your pie, head to I Tre Mori.

This spot is a favorite for its wood-fired, Neapolitan-inspired pizzas made with a delicate crust, simple tomato sauce, and top-quality mozzarella.

Distinctive Italian toppings and a wide wine selection set it apart from the pack.

The house favorite Margherita and truffle pies are top picks for a refined, cozy night out.

5. Bazbeaux Pizza

A beloved part of Indy’s pizza story for decades, Bazbeaux serves up thin-crust pies loaded with unique toppings, from artichoke hearts to Cajun shrimp and goat cheese.

With multiple locations and a lively atmosphere, Bazbeaux is a favorite for both vegetarians and meat lovers.

Their Quattro Formaggio and Popeye pies are must-try classics, and the build-your-own option means you can craft the perfect personal pizza.