5 Best Authentic Restaurants in Carmel, Indiana to Try

Carmel, IN, known for its upscale living and arts scene, also boasts a variety of authentic dining experiences.

Here are the five best authentic restaurants in Carmel that you absolutely must try.

Matt the Miller’s Tavern 

Matt the Miller’s Tavern serves American gastropub fare with a focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients.

Try their Buffalo Mac & Cheese, featuring tender chicken in a spicy buffalo sauce and creamy cheese.

Order the Fish and Chips, with crispy beer-battered cod and house-made tartar sauce.

Their Chocolate Fondue is a decadent dessert with fresh fruit and marshmallows for dipping.

The upscale yet casual setting at Matt the Miller’s Tavern makes it a beloved dining spot.

Woody’s Library Restaurant 

Woody’s Library Restaurant offers eclectic American dishes in a historic setting.

Try their Lobster Bisque, a creamy and rich soup with chunks of lobster.

Order the Chicken Pot Pie, featuring flaky pastry filled with tender chicken and vegetables.

Their Bread Pudding is a sweet dessert with a bourbon sauce.

Woody’s Library’s unique atmosphere and hearty dishes make it a must-visit.

Pizzology 

Pizzology serves artisanal pizzas with fresh, local ingredients in a casual environment.

Try their Margherita Pizza, topped with fresh mozzarella, basil, and tomato sauce.

Order the Sausage and Pepper Pizza, featuring house-made sausage and roasted peppers.

Their Tiramisu is a classic dessert with layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone.

Pizzology’s commitment to quality and flavor make it a favorite for pizza lovers.

Jamaican Reggae Grill 

Jamaican Reggae Grill offers authentic Jamaican cuisine in a vibrant and festive atmosphere.

Try their Jerk Chicken, marinated in a spicy jerk sauce and grilled to perfection.

Order the Curry Goat, a flavorful and tender dish with bold spices.

Their Rum Cake is a sweet and moist dessert with a hint of rum. Jamaican Reggae Grill’s bold flavors and lively vibe make it a standout spot.

Rize 

Rize serves healthy and organic dishes with a focus on fresh, locally-sourced ingredients.

Try their Avocado Toast, featuring fresh avocado on homemade bread.

Order the Superfood Salad, packed with nutritious ingredients like quinoa, kale, and berries.

Their Acai Bowl is a refreshing and healthy treat. Rize’s innovative menu and commitment to wellness make it a must-visit for health-conscious diners.