Milwaukee does beer, brats, and burgers as a way of life. From old‑school taverns to modern joints with griddled smashburgers, there’s no shortage of options—but these five get the loudest local love.
1. Sobelman’s Pub & Grill
If you ask Milwaukeeans for a burger recommendation, Sobelman’s comes up fast. It’s a classic MKE tavern taken to the next level, famous for both burgers and outrageous Bloody Marys.
The burgers:
- Big, juicy patties cooked on a flat‑top
- Tons of cheese, bacon, grilled onions, jalapeños, and other toppings
- Signature builds like the Sobelman’s or Hangover Burger, often stacked high
It’s messy, hearty, and pure Wisconsin comfort.
2. Oscar’s Pub & Grill
Oscar’s is another top‑tier favorite with a loyal following. Laid‑back bar vibe, sports on TV, and burgers that punch well above typical pub‑grub level.
Why locals swear by it:
- Thick, perfectly cooked patties with a deep sear
- Creative combos (think chorizo, avocado, fried jalapeños, multiple cheeses)
- Excellent fries and a solid craft beer list
The Big O and their daily specials are usually the move.
3. AJ Bombers
AJ Bombers blew up nationally after some TV attention, but locals were already in on it. It’s casual, fun, and a little gimmicky (peanuts delivered via “bombs”), but the burgers are genuinely good.
You’ll find:
- Smash‑style patties with crispy edges
- Classic American cheese, pickles, and special sauce builds
- Peanut butter and bacon burger options that sound odd but absolutely have a fanbase
If you like that perfect, diner‑style burger profile, AJ Bombers delivers.
4. Solly’s Grille
Solly’s is old‑school Milwaukee: a tiny counter, a griddle that’s been seasoned for decades, and butter burgers that define the style.
The deal:
- Thin, griddled patties
- An almost obscene amount of butter melted over the burger
- Simple American cheese, onions, and pickles
It’s rich, salty, buttery, and incredibly specific to this part of Wisconsin. Locals will insist you have to try it at least once.
5. Merriment Social
More modern and chef‑y, Merriment Social in Walker’s Point is where burger nerds go. While the menu is broad and seasonal, the Social Smash Burger has a near‑cult following.
It’s all about:
- Double smash patties with deep Maillard crust
- American cheese fully melted into the patties
- Shredded lettuce, pickles, onions, and a tangy sauce on a soft toasted bun
It’s a near‑perfect execution of the classic American burger formula, just done with better ingredients and more precision than your average spot.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
