Rochester has serious comfort‑food cred—from garbage plates to great pizza—and its burger scene lives right in that same lane. These five spots are always in the Rochester locals’ rotation when it comes to truly great burgers.
1. Vic & Irv’s / Schaller’s Area Favorites (classic drive‑in style)
Rochester’s old‑school burger and hot dog stands—places like Schaller’s—are core to the city’s identity. They’re usually simple buildings near the water or main roads, with counter service and a menu that hasn’t changed much in decades.
The burgers are thin, griddled, and come on soft buns with American cheese, onions, mustard, ketchup, and pickles. They’re not towering gourmet creations, but they taste exactly like summer in upstate New York. Add fries and maybe a Zweigles hot dog on the side and you’ll instantly get why locals are so loyal.
2. Tap & Mallet (and similar beer‑centric gastropubs)
Rochester’s craft‑beer bars often have one standout burger that regulars swear by. Tap & Mallet (and similar spots) pair a serious beer list with a small, focused menu where the burger is treated with real respect.
Think thick patties cooked to a proper medium, sharp cheddar or blue cheese, bacon, house pickles, and maybe an onion jam or aioli on a toasted bun. Fries come crisp and often can be upgraded or seasoned. Grab a local IPA or stout and it becomes the kind of burger meal you plan a whole evening around.
3. The Gate House
Located in Village Gate, The Gate House is a polished but approachable spot known for its wood‑fired pizzas and its burgers, which have their own cult following. The space is warm, with brick, wood, and a buzzing dining room.
The burger menu features both classics and creative combos—goat cheese and roasted red peppers, bacon and cheddar with BBQ sauce, or more adventurous options depending on the season. The patties are thick and juicy, buns are substantial, and everything feels thoughtfully composed rather than just stacked. Sweet potato fries or truffle fries are popular sides.
4. Bill Gray’s
Bill Gray’s is a local chain that proudly bills itself as having the “World’s Greatest Cheeseburger,” and while that might be up for debate, Rochester folks absolutely keep it in the best‑burger conversation. The vibe is casual, almost fast‑food‑meets‑diner, and very family‑friendly.
Burgers are griddled and generously sized, with melted American or cheddar, lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, and sauce on a toasted bun. You can upsize, add bacon, or go double if you’re hungry. Fries, onion rings, and milkshakes make it a full, very upstate New York fast‑casual experience.
5. Dogtown
Dogtown is better known for its hot dogs and creative toppings, but locals are quick to point out that the burgers here are seriously good too. The space is funky, colorful, and firmly in that casual, counter‑service niche.
The burgers are juicy, customizable, and often topped with the same imaginative combinations you see on their dogs—chili, slaw, onions, specialty sauces, and more. You can stick to a simple cheeseburger or go wild with toppings. Either way, it’s one of those laid‑back places where everything tastes like comfort food and nobody’s judging you for ordering big.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
