5 Best Hidden Gem Restaurants in Peoria, Illinois to Try

Peoria, Illinois, blends Midwest charm with urban sophistication, hosting a variety of delightful hidden gem restaurants.

Here are the five best hidden gem restaurants in Peoria that you need to uncover.

Edge by Chef Dustin Allen

Edge by Chef Dustin Allen provides an upscale dining experience with a focus on seasonal ingredients and innovative dishes in a stylish setting.

Try their Seared Scallops, perfectly cooked with a citrus glaze.

Order the Braised Short Ribs, tender and flavorful with a rich jus.

Their Crème Brûlée, creamy with a crisp caramel top, is a delightful dessert. 

Edge’s refined dishes and chic ambiance make it a standout.

Hearth

Hearth serves contemporary American cuisine with a focus on fresh, locally-sourced ingredients in an inviting atmosphere.

Try their Wild Mushroom Risotto, creamy and rich with flavorful mushrooms.

Order the Duck Breast, perfectly seared and paired with a tangy cherry reduction.

Their Chocolate Cake, rich and velvety with a hint of espresso, is a must-try dessert. 

Hearth’s inventive dishes and cozy vibe make it a local favorite.

The Fish House

The Fish House combines classic Midwestern seafood with innovative flavors in a relaxed, nautical-themed setting.

Try their Lobster Bisque, creamy and rich with tender lobster pieces.

Order the Crab Cakes, featuring tender lump crab with a zesty remoulade.

Their Key Lime Pie, tart and sweet with a graham cracker crust, is a delightful dessert. 

The Fish House’s hearty dishes and inviting atmosphere make it a top choice.

Table 19

Table 19 offers refined American cuisine with a focus on fresh, locally-sourced ingredients in an elegant, contemporary setting.

Try their Seared Tuna, perfectly cooked with a tangy citrus vinaigrette.

Order the Filet Mignon, tender and flavorful with a rich béarnaise sauce.

Their Chocolate Lava Cake, rich and velvety with a molten center, is a must-try dessert. 

Table 19’s refined dishes and chic ambiance make it a hidden gem.

Jim’s Steakhouse

Jim’s Steakhouse serves classic American steakhouse fare with a focus on high-quality ingredients in a stylish, yet relaxed environment.

Try their French Onion Soup, featuring a rich broth and melted cheese.

Order the Ribeye Steak, perfectly cooked and topped with herb butter.

Their Cheesecake, creamy and rich with a graham cracker crust, is a delightful dessert. 

Jim’s Steakhouse’s hearty dishes and inviting vibe make it a must-visit.