Carmel has transformed into one of the Indianapolis area’s most exciting dining destinations, thanks largely to its revitalized downtown and Arts & Design District. Stylish bistros, chef‑driven restaurants, and polished casual spots now line its walkable streets.
These five relatively new or newly buzz‑worthy restaurants are leading the way.
1. Anthony’s Chophouse
Anthony’s Chophouse brings big‑city steakhouse energy to Carmel’s city center.
The multi‑level space is sleek and modern, with floor‑to‑ceiling windows, dark wood accents, and a rooftop lounge that’s a scene in its own right.
The menu focuses on premium steaks and chops, carefully cooked and served with classic sides and sauces.
You’ll also find seafood towers, refined appetizers, and rich, shareable desserts. The wine list is extensive, and cocktails are crafted with care.
It’s very much a special‑occasion spot, though happy hour or a bar‑side dinner can feel surprisingly approachable.
2. Divvy
Divvy is all about shareable plates and a social atmosphere.
The dining room is stylish yet comfortable, with a bustling bar and a menu designed for ordering a little bit of everything.
Expect creative small plates that blend American and global influences: sliders, flatbreads, playful veggie dishes, seafood bites, and inventive takes on comfort food.
Many items are small enough to encourage trying three or four different things per person.
It’s perfect for groups and date nights where you want to linger over cocktails and food rather than rush through a single entree.
3. Eggshell Bistro
Eggshell Bistro sits just off Carmel’s Arts & Design District and offers a refined, almost European take on brunch.
The space is compact and artsy, with carefully curated decor that mirrors the thoughtfulness of the menu.
The dishes are creative and globally inspired—think elevated egg plates, tartines, seasonal vegetable preparations, and pastries that go far beyond standard brunch fare.
Coffee is taken seriously, with high‑quality beans and precise brewing methods.
If you’re into inventive, beautifully plated brunch in a cozy setting, this is a must‑visit.
4. Matt the Miller’s Tavern
Matt the Miller’s Tavern brings an upscale‑casual tavern feel to Carmel, with a big bar, plenty of seating, and a menu designed to please a crowd.
Food leans American gastropub: flatbreads, burgers, fish and chips, salads, pastas, and hearty entrees. A strong happy hour, rotating beer taps, and approachable cocktails make it popular for after‑work drinks and casual nights out.
It’s a versatile option for families, groups, and anyone looking for straightforward, well‑executed comfort food.
5. Bazbeaux Pizza (Carmel Location)
Bazbeaux is a long‑loved Indy pizza institution, and its Carmel outpost has quickly become a staple. The atmosphere is relaxed and family‑friendly, with indoor and outdoor seating that fits the walkable, bike‑friendly vibe of the area.
Pizzas come with thin, crisp‑yet‑chewy crusts and a wide range of topping combinations, from classic pepperoni to more adventurous options with gourmet cheeses and veggies. There are also salads, sandwiches, and a small but thoughtful beer and wine list.
It’s the go‑to when you want reliably excellent pizza in a laid‑back setting.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
