Allentown, Pennsylvania’s third-largest city, offers a pizza scene that reflects its industrial heritage, diverse communities, and Lehigh Valley traditions.
From old-world Italian to modern craft approaches, these five establishments represent Allentown’s best pizza in 2025.
1. Colonial Pizza & Spaghetti House
An Allentown landmark since 1958, Colonial Pizza maintains traditional Pennsylvania pizza culture with distinctive rectangular trays, medium-thick crust, and slightly sweet sauce.
Their signature style features cheese applied directly to the dough with sauce on top—unusual but beloved by generations of locals.
The “Colonial Special” combines Italian sausage, pepperoni, and green peppers on this exceptional foundation.
2. Salvatore’s Pizza
Representing classic Italian-American tradition, Salvatore’s delivers hand-tossed, New York-inspired pies with perfect crust texture and balanced toppings.
Available both by the slice and as whole pies, their pizza appeals to purists who appreciate quality execution of fundamentals.
The “Lehigh Valley Special” with extra cheese and pepperoni satisfies traditional tastes, while creative specials cater to evolving preferences.
3. Vegan Treats Bakery & Pizzeria
This groundbreaking establishment has gained national recognition for proving plant-based pizza can satisfy even traditional palates.
Their innovative approach features house-made vegan cheese alternatives and meat substitutes that deliver remarkable flavor and texture on a perfectly executed crust.
The “Buffalo Chick’n” convincingly recreates the classic flavor combination, while the “Garden Harvest” showcases seasonal produce from Pennsylvania farms.
4. Stooges Bar & Restaurant
This neighborhood favorite successfully combines quality pizza with a welcoming sports bar atmosphere.
Their distinctive style features a medium-thick crust with crispy edges, zesty sauce, and generous toppings.
The “Three Stooges Special” piles on multiple meats and vegetables for hearty satisfaction, while creative monthly specials keep the menu fresh.
The casual setting with multiple screens showing local and national sports creates a community gathering place that appeals to diverse age groups.
5. Quadrant Pizza
Representing Allentown’s emerging craft food scene, Quadrant brings artisanal approach and local sourcing to pizza.
Their naturally leavened sourdough crust develops complex flavor through 48-hour fermentation, while seasonal ingredients from Lehigh Valley farms create distinctive combinations.
The “Little Lehigh” with mushrooms from nearby specialty growers and Pennsylvania cheese showcases their local focus, while the “Steel Worker” with spicy soppressata honors Allentown’s industrial heritage.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
