5 Best Pizza Places in Amarillo, Texas to Try

Amarillo combines authentic Texas Panhandle heritage, Route 66 nostalgia, and unpretentious hospitality in this distinctive High Plains city.

These five pizzerias represent Amarillo’s best in 2025.

1. 575 Pizzeria

Named for the perfect cooking temperature, 575 Pizzeria brings artisanal approach and creative combinations to Amarillo with hand-crafted pies and local character.

Their medium-thin crust with perfect texture provides the foundation for both traditional favorites and innovative specialties like the “Omni” with green chile cream sauce and the “Amarillo by Morning” featuring local beef.

2. Texas Firehouse Pizza

Founded by actual firefighters, this local favorite serves hearty, hand-tossed pies with generous toppings and authentic Panhandle character.

Their signature style features medium-thick crust that stands up to abundant toppings, with the “Five Alarm” loaded with multiple meats and vegetables demonstrating their commitment to satisfying Texas-sized appetites.

3. Bella Pizza

This family-owned establishment brings traditional Italian-American recipes to Amarillo with hand-tossed pies featuring slightly sweet sauce and quality ingredients.

Founded by East Coast transplants who relocated to Texas, their commitment to authentic techniques includes deck ovens and hand-stretched dough that create perfect texture.

The “Bella Special” combines house-made Italian sausage and fresh vegetables on their excellent foundation, while efficient delivery service covers most Amarillo neighborhoods.

4. Route 66 Pizza Palace

Celebrating Amarillo’s iconic highway heritage, Route 66 Pizza serves classic American-style pies in a nostalgia-filled setting that honors the Mother Road’s legacy.

Their medium crust with slightly sweet sauce supports both traditional combinations and roadhouse-inspired specialties like the “Cadillac Ranch” named for Amarillo’s famous art installation.

The walls covered with Route 66 memorabilia and vintage automotive imagery create a distinctive atmosphere that attracts both locals and tourists exploring the historic highway.

5. Palace Coffee & Pizza Co.

This innovative concept combines specialty coffee culture with artisanal pizza in a contemporary space that represents Amarillo’s evolving food scene.

Their naturally leavened sourdough crust develops complex flavor through extended fermentation, while thoughtfully selected toppings create balanced combinations.

The “High Plains” features ingredients sourced from Texas Panhandle producers, while their coffee program showcases carefully selected beans and expert preparation.