Appleton, in the heart of the Fox Valley, boasts a thriving pizza scene built on a foundation of Midwest comfort and creative ambition.
Whether you’re searching for classic cheese-laden slices, wood-fired artisan pies, or bold, Wisconsin-inspired specialties, Appleton’s top pizzerias offer something for every pizza lover.
Here are the five best pizza places in Appleton for 2025, each beloved for quality, consistency, and true local flavor.
1. Stuc’s Pizza
A local institution since 1991, Stuc’s is famous for its massive, doughy hand-tossed crusts and hearty, saucy deep-dish pies.
Stuc’s offers a menu packed with creative specialty pizzas, calzones, and baked pasta—try the “Stuc’s Special” (a meat lover’s treat) or their signature stuffed pies.
The laid-back, family-friendly setting and generous portions make it a must-visit for newcomers and longtime residents alike.
2. SAL’S Pizza
True New York–style pizza is the draw at SAL’S—a favorite for huge, foldable slices and crispy, thin crust.
Regulars love their classic cheese and pepperoni, but the specialty topping combinations bring crowds as well.
Open late and perfect for takeout or a casual lunch, SAL’S brings an authentic East Coast flavor to central Wisconsin.
3. Cranky Pat’s Pizzeria & Pub
With origins dating back to 1955, Cranky Pat’s is a Fox Valley legend. The pies feature a cracker-thin crust, spicy tomato sauce, and cheese that stretches for miles.
Their “Pat’s Special” is loaded with sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers.
Retro charm, live music, and family-friendly vibes make this spot a longstanding local favorite.
4. zza Odyssey Pizzeria and Pub
Known for its unique topping combinations and welcoming craft beer list, zza Odyssey is a modern favorite.
Their menu features adventurous pies like the “Spartacus” (feta, sun-dried tomatoes, artichokes), gluten-free crusts, and lots of local sourcing.
The lively pub atmosphere is ideal for groups and those looking to try something a little different without losing the soul of good pizza.
5. Frank’s Pizza Palace
A downtown staple for over 60 years, Frank’s delivers classic, Italian-American thin crust pizza in a classic setting.
Old-school booths, cheerful service, and consistent, crispy pies with tangy sauce and lots of cheese make Frank’s a staple for families and pizza traditionalists.
Don’t miss out on their well-loved sausage or deluxe pies.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
