5 Best Pizza Places in Boulder, Colorado to Try

Boulder combines mountain town beauty, university energy, and that distinctive granola-meets-tech vibe.

Let me tell you about the pizza spots locals are obsessed with in 2025.

1. Barchetta

This Pearl Street gem creates sourdough pizzas with obsessive attention to fermentation that perfectly matches Boulder’s food-science-meets-hippie culture.

Their naturally leavened dough (which they’ll tell you ALL about if you ask) develops incredible flavor through 72-hour fermentation, while toppings from local farms create combinations that change weekly.

The “Flatiron” featuring seasonal foraged mushrooms is worth every penny of its admittedly Boulder-level price.

2. The Sink

This legendary University Hill institution has fueled CU students since 1923 with distinctive pies served in a space covered with decades of customer-created wall art.

Their oil-infused “Ugly Crust” pizza has a texture unlike anywhere else – crispy outside, soft inside – that generations of Buffs have craved during late-night study sessions.

The “Sink Burger” gives the pizza serious competition, but pizza is still king here.

3. Pizzeria Locale

This upscale spot (with Chipotle backing) brings authentic Neapolitan techniques to Boulder with imported Italian equipment and fanatical ingredient sourcing.

Their light, airy crusts with perfect leopard spotting support both traditional combinations and innovative specials featuring seasonal Colorado ingredients.

The contemporary space attracts a mix of tech professionals and food enthusiasts, while their perfectly curated Italian wine list enhances the experience.

4. Boss Lady Pizza

This woman-owned favorite near campus delivers creative pies with attitude and abundant toppings that satisfy both health-conscious vegans and hungry post-workout athletes.

Their diverse menu includes exceptional plant-based options alongside more traditional combinations, all on a crust that somehow satisfies both pizza purists and gluten-sensitive diners.

The casual, counter-service setup makes this perfect for grabbing a quick slice between classes or after a trail run.

5. Audrey Jane’s Pizza Garage

This unique spot brings East Coast attitude and exceptional technique to Boulder in a converted garage space with zero pretension.

The owner’s pizza obsession results in a perfect New York-style crust that somehow maintains ideal texture despite Colorado’s altitude challenges.

The “Jersey Boy” with perfectly crisped pepperoni cups is what regulars order, though the weekly specials showcase surprisingly creative combinations.