5 Best Pizza Places in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma to Try

Broken Arrow sits at the heart of Tulsa’s foodie energy, with a pizza scene that offers everything from Oklahoma classics to modern, wood-fired innovation.

Here are the city’s pizza standouts for 2025:

1. Andolini’s Pizzeria

Praised as one of Oklahoma’s top artisan pizza experiences, Andolini’s brings true Neapolitan technique—slow-fermented dough, imported Italian tomatoes, and mozzarella made in-house.

Their signature Margherita and “Demarco of Brooklyn” pies please purists, while “Honey Bastard” (with spicy honey and soppressata) wins foodies. Family-friendly, bustling, and always inventive.

2. Hideaway Pizza

An Oklahoma staple, Hideaway’s Broken Arrow outpost features thick, buttery crust or classic thin, tangy-sweet sauce, and topping-loaded specialties.

The “Paradise Pie” (chicken, smoked bacon, cheddar, sweet peppers) and the iconic “Big Country” are always hits.

Colorful décor and welcoming staff make Hideaway a celebration-ready pick.

3. Savastano’s Pizzeria

Broken Arrow’s answer to Chicago, Savastano’s is known for deep-dish, cheesy pies in a classic Windy City style.

Sausage, fresh tomato sauce, and gooey cheese are layered mile-high in every “Savastano’s Special” (add green pepper and onion).

With TVs, beer, and a cozy atmosphere, Savastano’s is perfect for sharing a pie with friends.

4. Mazzio’s Italian Eatery

A local favorite, Mazzio’s delivers big on value with hand-tossed, thick pan, and thin crust pizzas, including one of the area’s best “Pepperollies.”

Try their famous Taco Pizza or the “Combination.”

Kid-friendly, speedy delivery, and a full salad bar ensure there’s something for everyone.

5. Uncle Vinny’s NY Style Pizzeria

Authentic New York–style pies come fresh from the oven at Uncle Vinny’s. Slices are big, foldable, and perfectly crisped; the cheese is gooey, and toppings are high quality.

The “Grandma Pie” and classic Pepperoni are house faves.

Simple, fast, and delicious, it’s an East Coast fix in the heart of Oklahoma.