Buffalo’s pizza scene is defined by its own regional style—thick, airy crust with a crispy bottom, tangy sweet sauce, and generous cheese—alongside a mix of authentic Neapolitan, New York–style slices, and modern gastropub pies.
Whether you’re a Buffalo native searching for your new go-to or a visitor hungry for local flavor, these five spots offer the best, most distinctive pies in the Queen City for 2025.
1. Hydraulic Hearth Restaurant & Brewery
Hydraulic Hearth excels with modern wood-fired pizzas served in a vibrant, brewery-meets-restaurant atmosphere.
Their craft pies often feature local ingredients, creative combinations, and a perfectly blistered, chewy crust.
Pair your pizza with a house-brewed beer and enjoy the fun, communal feel or the spacious outdoor beer garden for ultimate Buffalo vibes.
2. Frankie Primo’s +39
A favorite for both locals and visitors, Frankie Primo’s +39 puts an Italian trattoria spin on Buffalo-style pizza.
Expect a well-balanced, crispy crust, tangy red sauce, and premium toppings—served alongside classic antipasti and a strong wine list.
Their warm, bustling setting in downtown Buffalo makes it perfect for date night or friends’ gatherings.
3. Bocce Club Pizza
A Buffalo pizza institution, Bocce Club has been slinging signature square pies for decades.
The crust is thick but airy, perfectly golden with cheese all the way to the edge, and topped with that slightly sweet regional sauce.
Whether you dine in or order delivery, Bocce’s consistency and legacy make it mandatory for a true taste of Buffalo.
4. Imperial Pizza
Known for serving up some of the city’s cheesiest, sauciest pies, Imperial Pizza is a late-night legend and a beloved local hangout.
Load up a classic Buffalo-style sheet pizza with pepperoni and banana peppers, and you’ll see why lines form here on weekends.
Their takeout game is especially strong—great for parties or watching the Bills with friends.
5. Lovejoy Pizza
Lovejoy is a neighborhood staple, dishing out hearty, flavorful Buffalo-style pies with a loyal following.
The crust is substantial but crisp, the sauce leans sweet, and toppings are generous. No-frills, no fuss, just great pizza and friendly service—making Lovejoy Pizza a must-visit for anyone exploring Buffalo’s local flavor.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
