Cape Coral’s pizza scene is booming, with classic Italian pizzerias, authentic New York–style pies, inventive toppings, and a welcoming Gulf Coast vibe.
Whether you’re craving a classic slice, deep-dish indulgence, or gluten-free options, these top pizzerias deliver quality, hospitality, and flavor that keep locals and visitors coming back for more.
Here are the five best pizza spots in Cape Coral for 2025—each earning high marks for taste, consistency, and service.
1. Maria’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
One of the highest-rated and most beloved pizzerias in Cape Coral, Maria’s delivers outstanding Italian-style pizzas with a focus on quality ingredients and perfectly balanced flavors.
Their menu includes both traditional and creative options, consistently earning rave reviews for taste, portion size, and friendly service.
Maria’s is a dependable go-to for dine-in, takeout, and delivery.
2. Luciano’s Pizza
Luciano’s is a family-owned, New York–style pizzeria famous for its hand-made dough, homemade Italian sauces, and signature cannoli cream desserts.
With an authentic pizzeria ambiance, generous portions, and standouts like their cheese steak stromboli and pepperoni rolls, Luciano’s wins the loyalty of both locals and New York transplants who crave a true slice of home.
3. Paradise Pizza
With a near-perfect customer rating, Paradise Pizza is Cape Coral’s go-to for gluten-free pies without sacrificing flavor or texture.
Their special gluten-free dough and extensive topping options attract those with dietary requirements and anyone seeking something different, with the “Paradise Special” and classic cheese pie always in high demand.
4. Lelulo’s Pizzeria
Regulars praise Lelulo’s for its delicious pizzas, creative flavor combinations, and speedy, reliable delivery service.
The menu spans classic to bold—try the “Chicken Inferno” topped with Mike’s Hot Honey, ranch, and fried chicken—or stick with old-school standards for a crowd-pleaser.
Lelulo’s stands out for fast service and attention to detail, whether you’re eating in or taking out.
5. Chicago Pizza
In Cape Coral, Chicago Pizza is the place to indulge in classic deep-dish style pies—full of cheese, savory tomato sauce, and your choice of ample toppings.
As the name suggests, they specialize in that signature thick, bowl-shaped crust that holds up to generous portions.
With a wide menu and a reputation for hearty comfort food, Chicago Pizza is a must-visit for lovers of heavy, saucy, and satisfying slices.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
