Columbia, Missouri—a thriving college town—offers a dynamic pizza scene with something for everyone.
From iconic campus favorites to creative local innovators and classic family-run gems, the city’s best pizzerias blend tradition, bold flavors, and Mizzou spirit.
Here are the top five pizza places in Columbia for 2025, chosen for their quality, originality, and loyal fanbases.
1. Pizza Tree
Routinely recognized as Columbia’s most innovative pizzeria, Pizza Tree dazzles diners with creative toppings and bold flavor combinations.
The “Jalapeño Papa” topped with pepper jack, jalapeños, and a honey drizzle is a standout, offering a spicy-sweet bite that has earned cult status.
Their Mac and Cheese pizza and walk-up window vibe make this spot a standout for adventurous eaters, late-night crowds, and slice lovers alike.
2. Pappo’s Pizzeria & Pub
Pappo’s is praised for its high-quality ingredients, hand-tossed dough, and well-balanced specialty pies loaded with flavorful toppings.
The “Deluxe” (pepperoni, sausage, red onion, mushrooms, green peppers) and Shrimp Scampi pizza are prime examples of their creative yet harmonious approach.
A welcoming pub environment and solid craft beer selection make this a hit with groups and families.
3. Shakespeare’s Pizza
No list is complete without Columbia’s pizza legend, Shakespeare’s.
Famed for its thick cheese layer, generous slice portions, and distinctive dry crust, Shakespeare’s remains a campus tradition and alumni favorite.
Whether grabbing a slice at the classic downtown shop or ordering a specialty pie, the quirky atmosphere and consistent quality keep this iconic pizzeria at the top.
4. Gumby’s Pizza
A quirky chain beloved by college students, Gumby’s wins fans with offbeat specialty pies (like the signature Pesto Chicken with feta and red onion) and consistently good cheese-to-sauce ratios.
Soft yet sturdy crusts, fair prices, and popular Pokey Stix breadsticks make it essential for late-night orders and group feasts.
5. Wise Guys
Tucked inside McNally’s Irish Pub, Wise Guys offers classic, well-executed pies—with a special emphasis on Chicago-style deep dish, as well as reliable thin-crust options.
Their Meat Lover’s and cheese pizzas are celebrated for their balanced flavors and hearty toppings, earning Wise Guys local praise for delivering satisfying, no-nonsense pizza at great prices.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
