Coral Springs combines planned suburban comfort, family-friendly amenities, and South Florida diversity in this distinctive Broward County city.
These five pizzerias represent Coral Springs’ best in 2025.
1. Pasquale’s Pizza & Subs
This family-owned establishment brings authentic New York-Italian quality to Coral Springs with hand-tossed pies featuring thin, foldable crusts and perfect cheese-to-sauce balance.
The “Coral Springs Special” combines traditional toppings on their excellent foundation, while their Sicilian square pizza offers a heartier alternative that’s achieved local fame.
The welcoming atmosphere reflects genuine family hospitality, creating connections with regular customers across multiple generations.
2. Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza
This South Florida success story (founded in nearby Fort Lauderdale) delivers distinctive “well-done” pizzas from 900-degree coal ovens that create uniquely charred, crisp crusts with chewy interiors.
Their simple, high-quality toppings like Italian imports and fresh mozzarella shine on this exceptional base.
The “Paul & Young Ron” with meatballs and ricotta has developed a regional following, while their roasted cauliflower pizza demonstrates creative vegetable applications.
3. Tavolino Della Nonna
This upscale Italian restaurant brings wood-fired Neapolitan traditions to Coral Springs with authentic techniques and premium ingredients.
Their light, airy crusts with perfect leopard spotting provide the foundation for both traditional combinations and creative specialties featuring seasonal Florida produce.
The elegant yet family-friendly atmosphere makes Tavolino suitable for both special occasions and elevated casual dining.
4. Brooklyn Boys Pizza
Founded by authentic Brooklyn transplants, this neighborhood favorite delivers genuine New York slices with the perfect fold, balanced sauce, and quality cheese.
Their commitment to authenticity includes importing water with mineral content similar to NYC’s to create the ideal dough texture.
The casual, family-friendly setting makes Brooklyn Boys perfect for quick lunches and weeknight dinners, while efficient takeout serves busy Coral Springs families.
Beyond pizza, their complete Italian-American menu satisfies diverse cravings.
5. The Pizza Press
This build-your-own concept combines customization with quality through thin-crust personal pizzas with newspaper-themed creativity.
The “Chronicle” with pepperoni and mushrooms and the “Tribune” with chicken and bacon satisfy traditional tastes, while unlimited custom options accommodate diverse preferences.
The modern, family-friendly space at The Walk shopping center attracts diners seeking both quality and convenience.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
