5 Best Pizza Places in Cushing, Oklahoma to Try

Cushing combines oil industry heritage, small town charm, and authentic Oklahoma character.

Here’s where locals find their favorite pizza in 2025.

1. Buffalo’s Pizza & Ice Cream

This Cushing institution has been serving hand-tossed pies since long before “pipeline crossroads of the world” became a trendy place to visit.

Their slightly sweet sauce and perfect crust with just the right chew create that nostalgic flavor that generations of oil workers and locals consider the definition of “Cushing pizza.”

The vintage setting with oil industry memorabilia creates authentic connections to the town’s defining industry, while their famous ice cream provides the perfect dessert complement.

2. Pipeline Pizza & Pub

Named for Cushing’s famous oil storage facilities, this downtown spot serves quality pies in a setting that celebrates the town’s unique place in American energy infrastructure.

Their hand-tossed crusts support creative combinations with oil-inspired names like the “Crude Special” loaded with multiple meats and the “Pumpjack” featuring locally-sourced ingredients.

3. Cushing Firehouse Pizza

Founded by actual firefighters, this local favorite serves hearty, hand-tossed pies with generous toppings and authentic small-town character.

Their signature style features medium-thick crust that stands up to abundant toppings, with the “Five Alarm” loaded with multiple meats and vegetables demonstrating their commitment to satisfying hearty Oklahoma appetites.

The distinctive firehouse-themed setting with memorabilia donated by the local department creates unique atmosphere while honoring first responders.

4. Simple Simon’s Pizza

This regional Oklahoma chain’s Cushing location has distinguished itself through exceptional execution and genuine community involvement.

Their hand-tossed pies feature consistent quality and generous toppings at prices that respect Cushing’s working-class character.

The spacious, family-friendly environment makes this perfect for youth sports celebrations and birthday parties, while efficient takeout operations serve practical family needs.

5. The Derrick Diner & Pizza

This unique concept combines classic American diner fare with quality pizza under one roof, satisfying diverse cravings with equal excellence.

Their hand-tossed pies feature both traditional toppings and creative combinations inspired by diner classics like the “Breakfast Pizza” topped with eggs and bacon.

Beyond pizza, their complete diner menu makes this a versatile dining option where families with varied preferences can all find satisfaction.