Deltona’s pizza world brings together classic Italian-American pies, New York–style slices, and the easygoing spirit of Central Florida.
These five spots top the local charts in 2025.
1. Goodfella’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant
A beloved Deltona anchor, Goodfella’s crafts hearty, hand-tossed pizzas with authentic red sauce, gooey cheese, and crisp, chewy crusts.
The “Goodfella’s Supreme” (pepperoni, sausage, bell peppers, onions, olives, and mushrooms) shows off their Italian heritage.
Pasta and sub options complete the classic Italian-American experience, and locals rave about the generous portions and quick, friendly service.
2. Angelina’s Pizzeria
A New York transplant’s dream, Angelina’s dishes up big, foldable slices and whole pies loaded with fresh mozzarella, quality toppings, and a crackly, airy base.
Favorites include the “Eggplant Parmigiana Pizza” and the “Meatlovers.”
Counter service is fast—perfect for lunch, quick dinner, or takeout for the whole family.
3. Papa’s Pizza
A longtime family favorite for both dine-in and delivery, Papa’s is known for its classic round pies—crisp-edged, cheesy, and customizable.
The “Papa’s Special” (everything but the kitchen sink!) is always a hit, and the loaded garlic knots and wings make this a go-to for casual nights and parties.
4. Vinny’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Vinny’s stands out for its old-school charm, relaxed setting, and menu of Italian comfort.
Their pizza features a medium-thick crust, sweet marinara, and a great ratio of cheese to sauce, with popular specialties like “Bianca Florentina” (spinach, ricotta, garlic, mozzarella) and “Sicilian Meat Lovers.”
Friendly, patient service and homemade cannoli are bonuses.
5. Domu Pizzeria and Restaurant
A newer addition making waves, Domu offers both NY- and Sicilian-style pies, bold specialty options like “Buffalo Ranch Chicken” and “Truffle Mushroom,” and gluten-free dough.
Modern, clean, and upbeat, Domu is great for adventurous palettes and the Instagram generation.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
