5 Best Pizza Places in Fort Wayne, Indiana to Try

Fort Wayne’s pizza scene is a heartland blend of tried-and-true family-run pizzerias, classic Midwestern comfort, and exciting new-school flavor.

Expect everything from craveworthy, cheese-loaded pies to cracker-thin crusts, innovative specialties, and an unmistakable Hoosier welcome.

Here are the five best pizza spots in Fort Wayne for 2025—each with a loyal base and a flavorful slice of northeast Indiana pride.

1. 816 Pint & Slice

Downtown’s beloved Pint & Slice offers the quintessential urban pizza experience: huge New York–style slices, chewy crust, quick service, and an ever-bustling vibe.

Locals rave about their classic cheese, pepperoni, and loaded specialty pies—plus the perfect pairing of pizza with one of their many craft beers on tap.

With late hours and a prime location, it’s a top choice for a casual lunch, post-game snack, or night out.

2. Oley’s Pizza Shoppe

An institution since the 1980s, Oley’s is the go-to for lovers of ultra-thick, cheesy, indulgent pies.

They’re best known for their deep-dish “Big O” pizza—pillowy hand-tossed dough, mountains of fresh cheese, and a flavor-packed homemade sauce.

Portions are massive, toppings are generous, and their laid-back, family-run atmosphere makes every visit feel like a special occasion.

3. The Hoppy Gnome (Gnometown Pizza)

While The Hoppy Gnome is widely known for its upscale tacos and craft beer, their Gnometown Pizza inside the same space has swiftly built a following.

They impress with inventive, wood-fired pizzas—featuring everything from local sausage to roasted veggies and bold, global flavors.

The downtown setting and adventurous pies add variety and sophistication to Fort Wayne’s pizza lineup.

4. Mad Anthony Brewing Company

This local craft brewery has built a reputation for quality pizza, pairing hearty house-made pies with award-winning beers.

Their menu boasts hand-tossed crusts, creative toppings, and pizza flights that let you sample several varieties at once.

Known for both carnivore and veggie-friendly options, Mad Anthony’s is a lively hangout for foodies and beer fans alike.

5. Toppings Pizza

A North Fort Wayne favorite, Toppings Pizza stands out for customization, letting you pick from dozens of toppings for your perfect pie.

Their traditional round pizzas are reliably crispy, topped edge-to-edge, and offered at wallet-friendly prices.

Locals highlight Toppings’ fast, friendly service, generous portions, and everything-from-scratch mentality, making it a hit for families, takeout, and delivery.