5 Best Pizza Places in Fresno, California to Try

Fresno may be famous for its central role in California’s farm-to-table movement, but it’s quickly becoming a sought-after city for pizza lovers too.

With a lively blend of classic Italian-American recipes, wood-fired artisan pies, and locally sourced ingredients, Fresno’s best pizzerias offer both comfort and culinary creativity.

Here are the top five pizza places in Fresno for 2025, guaranteed to satisfy every slice seeker.

1. Annesso Pizzeria

Recognized as the 2025 “Best Pizza” winner by the California Restaurant Association’s Best of the Valley Awards, Annesso Pizzeria stands out for its elevated approach to traditional Italian pizza.

Known for its hand-stretched, perfectly blistered crust, Annesso’s pies are loaded with inventive toppings—think house-cured meats, fresh mozzarella, and farm-fresh produce.

Chef Jimmy Pardini, also named “Chef of the Year,” brings a fine-dining background to the wood-fired oven, ensuring every pizza is a memorable experience.

Both locals and critics consider Annesso a must-visit for pizza aficionados seeking sophistication and flavor.

2. Mama Mia Pizzaria

Mama Mia Pizzaria is beloved for its no-nonsense, family-style comfort and consistently delicious pies.

Their approach is classic—fluffy-yet-crisp crusts, hearty red sauce, stretchy cheese, and generous toppings.

Customers return often for the signature combo and meat lovers’ pies, as well as a relaxed, welcoming vibe perfect for families and groups.

Mama Mia’s reputation as a neighborhood staple, along with high praise for its delivery and takeout, cements its spot among Fresno’s best.

3. Marcelino’s Wood Fired Pizza

As the name suggests, Marcelino’s specializes in authentic wood-fired pizza, complete with beautifully charred crust and a subtle smokiness that sets it apart.

Toppings include classic Margherita, spicy soppressata, and local California produce, served in a modern, airy setting.

Marcelino’s is a favorite for both pizza purists and those looking for something a little more gourmet.

The restaurant’s friendly team and consistent quality have helped it earn accolades regionally and attract pizza fans from all over.

4. Hot Rod Willy’s Pizza

Hot Rod Willy’s has built a loyal following for its hearty, customizable pies and “the works” approach to toppings.

Offering both thin and thick crust options, huge sizes, and an old-school, car-themed atmosphere, it’s a favorite for casual gatherings and parties.

Diners rave about the spicy pepperoni, fresh veggies, and hefty cheese pulls.

Their quick service and strong delivery reputation make Hot Rod Willy’s a local go-to for pizza nights at home.

5. Russo’s New York Pizzeria

Bringing an authentic slice of the East Coast to the Central Valley, Russo’s New York Pizzeria excels at traditional, foldable NY-style pies with a chewy, flavorful crust.

Expect massive slices, fresh tomato sauce, and classic toppings from sausage to mushrooms.

Russo’s is especially popular for both dine-in and takeout, and their pasta and sub menu rounds out the comfort food appeal.

The spot attracts locals craving a taste of New York and families wanting a big, satisfying meal.