Gainesville’s pizza scene is an energetic mix of student favorites, classic local institutions, artisan pies, and bold, creative chefs.
Whether you’re cheering on the Gators, exploring downtown, or just looking for a great slice, these top five pizza spots guarantee a memorable meal and a taste of North Florida charm.
Here are the best pizza places in Gainesville for 2025, celebrated for their quality, character, and loyal fans.
1. Satchel’s Pizza
A true Gainesville legend, Satchel’s Pizza is beloved for its funky, artsy vibe and inventive, scratch-made pies.
Known for its chewy, bubbly crust, house-made sauce, and generous toppings, Satchel’s offers classic and specialty pizzas, fresh salads, and homemade sodas—all in a quirky, colorful setting with vintage vans and eclectic art everywhere.
Expect a wait, especially on weekends, but the flavor and atmosphere make it all worthwhile.
2. Blue Highway a Pizza Joint
Blue Highway brings artisan flair with hand-tossed dough, locally sourced produce, and a diverse menu of both classic and creative pies.
Their wood-fired ovens turn out perfectly blistered crusts topped with everything from prosciutto and arugula to buffalo chicken.
The casual, welcoming atmosphere is ideal for families, date nights, or post-game feasts. Gluten-free and vegan options are also available.
3. Midici – The Neapolitan Pizza Company
For Naples-style pizza in Gainesville, Midici delivers the real deal: handmade, naturally leavened dough, San Marzano tomatoes, fior di latte mozzarella, and creative toppings baked in a blistering wood-fired oven.
Their open kitchen, modern setting, and Italian-inspired small plates and desserts make Midici perfect for foodies and anyone seeking something a notch above the ordinary.
4. Leonardo’s Pizza Millhopper
Leonardo’s is a longtime Gainesville staple, renowned for thick, cheesy pies and piled-high toppings.
Their famous “Monster Slice” is a rite of passage for UF students and hungry locals.
The laid-back, nostalgic atmosphere and extra-generous portions make Leonardo’s a prime pick for families, groups, and big appetites.
The garlic knots and dessert rolls are as legendary as the pizza itself.
5. Big Lou’s NY Style Pizzeria
Big Lou’s brings classic New York–style pizza to downtown Gainesville—think thin, foldable slices, a crisp crust, bubbly cheese, and a tangy house sauce.
Their menu covers all the crowd-pleasing options, from pepperoni and veggie to white pies, along with hearty calzones and heroes.
Open late and perfect for takeout, Big Lou’s is a go-to for Gator game days and night-out cravings.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
