Grand Rapids boasts a vibrant pizza landscape, ranging from creative artisan ovens and classic Italian-American pizzerias to craft beer-and-pie pairings and family favorites.
The city’s pizza scene is a showcase of West Michigan’s attention to quality ingredients, local pride, and inventive flavors.
Here are the top five pizza spots in Grand Rapids for 2025—each setting the standard for exceptional slices and memorable experiences.
1. Quarantino’s Pizza
Quarantino’s has quickly earned a reputation as Grand Rapids’ top-rated pizzeria, thanks to its 4.6/5 Yelp rating and passionate fanbase.
Serving up a mix of classic and inventive pies, Quarantino’s is known for perfectly chewy dough, well-seasoned sauce, and creative specials that keep regulars coming back.
The cozy atmosphere and consistent quality have cemented its status as the city’s must-try pizza spot.
2. Martha’s Pizza
Martha’s Pizza, also ranked at a stellar 4.6/5, delights guests with high-quality cheese, fresh toppings, and a balance of crispy and chewy crust.
With classic flavor options and a focus on hospitality, Martha’s stands out for both flavor and simple, satisfying offerings.
Their signature pies are a draw for locals looking for reliably great pizza in a friendly setting.
3. Greco’s Pizza
Greco’s Pizza impresses with a 4.5/5 rating, earning loyalty for its robust sauce, hearty slices, and excellent value.
The family-friendly feeling and classic Italian-American options make Greco’s a perennial favorite, perfect for weeknight dinners or casual gatherings.
Their blend of tradition and consistency keeps their customer base coming back, slice after slice.
4. Russo’s Pizza
Russo’s Pizza achieves a near-perfect 4.4/5, specializing in Italian-style pies with a crispy, flavorful crust and a fresh, bright sauce.
Locals love the quality of ingredients, generous toppings, and quick, friendly service.
Russo’s offers both traditional and specialty pizzas in a welcoming environment, making it a go-to for families and anyone seeking a taste of Italy in West Michigan.
5. The Mitten Brewing Co.
Combining a passion for craft beer and gourmet pizza, The Mitten Brewing Co. delivers one of Grand Rapids’ most unique dining experiences.
Their pizzas are lauded for inventive combinations like the Westerdog (which features local bratwurst, chips, and beer mustard) alongside classics and gluten-free options.
The venue, a restored firehouse, is a draw in itself, and the beers are expertly matched to their pies.
With a robust 4.3/5 rating and hundreds of rave reviews, The Mitten tops the list for pizza and beer lovers alike.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
