Jacksonville’s food scene is on the rise, and pizza is a star player—thanks to a mix of classic family-owned pizzerias, cozy neighborhood joints, and spots pushing the boundaries of what pizza can be.
Whether you love thin New York slices, want crispy Neapolitan crust, or just crave the best pepperoni in town, these are the five standout pizza places to check out when in Jacksonville.
1. Carmine’s Pie House
Carmine’s Pie House is a Riverside favorite that delivers big on both Chicago-style and New York-style pizzas.
The vibe is a classic, laid-back neighborhood pizzeria with a deep menu of not just pizzas but also Italian subs, wings, and hearty pasta.
Their pies are known for generous, quality toppings, gooey cheese, and perfectly crisp crusts.
Locals love the welcoming atmosphere, big slices, and fun environment—making it a must-stop for both families and pizza connoisseurs alike.
2. V Pizza
V Pizza is known citywide for its authentic Italian brick-oven pizzas, cooked at high heat for that irresistible balance of crispy edges and tender, subtly chewy centers.
Using imported Italian ingredients and traditional Napoletana techniques, V Pizza consistently earns rave reviews for pies like the Margherita, the spicy Diavola, and even creative chicken and BBQ varieties.
Multiple locations—San Marco, Mandarin, and Jacksonville Beach—mean you’re never too far from a wood-fired masterpiece.
3. Tony D’s New York Pizza
Craving a true New York slice? Tony D’s New York Pizza & Restaurant brings authentic, giant, foldable slices to Jacksonville.
Their dough and sauce recipes are inspired by the pizzerias of NYC, and the menu features both classics and specialty pies.
Guests praise the fresh, high-quality toppings and that perfect, slightly crispy, chewy crust—plus awesome service and a welcoming, relaxed setting.
4. Moon River Pizza
Moon River Pizza is a real local gem with a loyal following for a reason: their pizzas are made fresh, never skimping on quality.
Their pies are loaded with cheese and toppings, the crust is a delicious balance of crunch and chew, and the variety makes it easy to find your perfect combo.
With a fun, laid-back vibe, friendly staff, and local beer, Moon River delivers a classic, much-loved Jacksonville pizza experience.
5. Pie95 Pizza
Pie95 Pizza is an up-and-coming favorite, especially for pizza lovers who seek a blend of tradition and innovation.
Known for its creative selection and signature hand-crafted dough, Pie95 specializes in wood-fired pies and offers everything from classic pepperoni to inventive, gourmet specialties.
The “Perfect Pepperoni” and unique Romantica pies stand out among local pizza fanatics, and their garlic boat is a must-order side.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
