Kalamazoo, home to universities, breweries, and a creative downtown energy, boasts a pizza scene that blends tradition, quirky invention, and true Michigan comfort.
Whether it’s wood-fired Neapolitan, loaded deep dish, or a classic NY slice, these five places define Kalamazoo pizza excellence for 2025.
1. Bruno’s Pizza & Restaurant
A Kalamazoo icon since the 1950s, Bruno’s represents pure local tradition: dough made daily, rich house sauce, lots of gooey cheese, and square-cut party pieces.
Their “Super Combo” (sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, pepperoni) or classic cheese pies are must-tries, and their full menu of Italian-American comfort food makes this a staple for families and students alike.
The retro booths and fast service complete the charm.
2. Bimbo’s Pizza
Downtown’s beloved hole-in-the-wall, Bimbo’s specializes in old-school, thin-crust pies bursting with flavor.
The “Bimbo’s Special” (sausage, mushroom, pepperoni), hearty Sicilian squares, and white garlic pies are favorites, and the nostalgic, bustling counter-service vibe is as Kalamazoo as it gets.
Don’t forget dessert: Bimbo’s cinnamon breadsticks have their own local following.
3. Principle Food & Drink
Better known for craft cocktails and chef-driven small plates, Principle’s wood-fired pizzas have quickly made an impression on Kalamazoo’s foodies.
Expect blistered, airy crust, local produce, and seasonal specialties like “Wild Mushroom & Truffle” or “Spicy Honey Pepperoni.”
With a trendy, urban setting and a top-tier beverage program, Principle is ideal for date nights or foodie adventures.
4. Erbelli’s Gourmet Pizzeria
For loaded creative pies and crowd-pleasing flavors, Erbelli’s is a west-side favorite.
With a huge menu, gluten-free options, and zesty specialty combos (try the “Erbbie’s Supreme” or “Roadhouse BBQ Chicken”), Erbelli’s stands out for inventive toppings, mega portions, and a no-nonsense, family-friendly vibe. Delivery and carryout are always fast and reliable.
5. Martini’s Pizza
Near campus, Martini’s brings together gourmet hand-tossed pizzas, calzones, and Italian-inspired apps in a buzzy, modern space.
Their “Popeye Pie” (spinach, ricotta, mozzarella, garlic butter) is legendary, as are their build-your-own options and creative rotating specials.
Locals love the craft beer list and dog-friendly patio for a relaxed, social meal.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
