5 Best Pizza Places in Milwaukee to Try Today

Milwaukee’s pizza scene is a delicious testament to the city’s melting-pot spirit—mixing Old World Italian tradition with Midwest inventiveness and local pride.

Whether you crave Neapolitan-style wood-fired pies, tavern-cut classics, hearty Sicilian, or cutting-edge flavors, Milwaukee offers something for every type of pizza fan.

Here are the five top pizza places in Milwaukee for 2025, each garnering rave reviews and loyal local followings.

1. Maggio’s Wood Fired Pizza

Maggio’s Wood Fired Pizza stands out as Milwaukee’s top-rated pie shop, earning an impressive 4.7/5 from diners.

Known for blistered, chewy crusts straight from a real wood-fired oven, Maggio’s pies feature top-quality mozzarella, house-made sauces, and a rotating selection of classic and seasonal toppings.

Their cozy Wauwatosa location and expertly crafted pizzas make every visit special, whether you choose a classic Margherita or a chef’s specialty.

2. Brothers Gyros & Pizza

Brothers Gyros & Pizza masterfully blends Greek and Italian influences, offering a menu heavy on flavor and friendly service.

Their pizza boasts a crispy crust and signature zesty sauce, and toppings are generous.

Standouts include their fusion pies—like gyros pizza—and classic pepperoni or sausage, all earning the shop a stellar 4.7/5 rating from hundreds of happy customers.

3. Santino’s Little Italy

A perennial favorite, Santino’s Little Italy brings authentic Italian-American hospitality and hearty, traditional pies to the city’s south side.

Reviewers rave about the deeply flavorful sauce, ample cheese, classic meatballs, and the satisfying crunch of their crust.

Santino’s ranks among the city’s best with its robust 4.7/5 score and inviting old-school ambience—don’t miss their classic pepperoni or specialty pies inspired by family recipes.

4. San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana

For those craving true Neapolitan pizza, San Giorgio delivers with certified techniques and imported Italian ingredients.

Each pie is blistered quickly in a wood-fired oven, ensuring delicate chew, slightly smoky crust, and bright flavors.

Try the Margherita or signature Fantasia with prosciutto and arugula—San Giorgio’s 4.5/5 rating and central downtown location make it a favorite with both purists and adventurers.

5. Transfer Pizzeria Café

Transfer Pizzeria Café is beloved for its artisanal approach, inventive seasonal offerings, and a welcoming neighborhood vibe in Walker’s Point.

Patrons dig the chewy, flavorful crust, sharp Wisconsin cheese, funky toppings (like seafood and vegan chorizo), and gluten-free choices.

Transfer’s high volume of glowing reviews matches its 4.1/5 rating—making it a go-to for anyone wanting something a little different without sacrificing quality.