Murfreesboro, home to MTSU and a fast-growing community, blends Southern hospitality with pizza traditions new and old.
Whether you love classic hometown pies, gourmet flair, or big NY-style slices, these five pizzerias deliver the area’s best in 2025.
1. Slick Pig BBQ & Pizza
An unexpected combo that works—Slick Pig is famous for finger-licking smoked wings, but their pizza holds equal legend status.
The pies are hand-tossed, thick, and topped with plenty of cheese, hearty sauce, and even barbecue pork for a true Tennessee twist.
It’s a must for anyone seeking Southern flavor with their slice.
2. Sal’s Pizza
A staple for New York–style pies, Sal’s delivers huge, foldable slices, perfectly crisp crust, and servings you can barely finish in one sitting.
Pepperoni, veggie, and white pizzas are best sellers—no fuss, just classic pies in a cozy, counter-serve spot.
Fast service and fair prices keep Sal’s packed with college kids and families alike.
3. Casanova’s Italian Cuisine
Casanova’s brings the traditions of Italy right to Murfreesboro, serving artisan thin-crust pizzas with San Marzano tomatoes, buffalo mozzarella, and hand-selected toppings.
The “Quattro Formaggi” and “Margherita” earn rave reviews, and the romantic, family-owned vibe is perfect for a laid-back night out.
Their pasta and homemade desserts also shine.
4. Sir Pizza
No Murfreesboro pizza roundup is complete without Sir Pizza, the regional chain known for its ultra-thin, square-cut slices, edge-to-edge toppings, and crispy, buttery crust.
The “Royal Feast,” loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and green peppers, has nostalgic appeal.
The vintage feel and quick service keep the dining room bustling.
5. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s takes classic American pizza and gives it a modern spin, with thick, hearty hand-tossed or thin crusts, build-your-own options, and popular specialties like the “White Cheezy” or “Deluxe.”
Delivery is fast and reliable, and the extensive menu (with wings, subs, and salads) makes it a hit for families and parties.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
