Olathe, Kansas combines suburban comfort with Midwestern hospitality in this growing Kansas City suburb.
From family-friendly chains to creative local spots, these five pizzerias represent Olathe’s best in 2025.
1. Waldo Pizza
This beloved Kansas City institution’s Olathe location brings artisanal pizza with Midwestern hospitality to the suburbs.
Their hand-tossed, medium-thick crust provides the perfect foundation for both classic combinations and creative specialties.
The “Waldo Classic” with Italian sausage and mushrooms satisfies traditional tastes, while the “KC BBQ” with burnt ends and Kansas City sauce showcases regional flavor.
Their extensive selection of local craft beers complements the menu perfectly.
2. Papa Keno’s Pizzeria
Famous for enormous, East Coast-style slices bigger than your face, Papa Keno’s delivers big flavor alongside impressive size.
Their thin, foldable crust maintains perfect texture despite its massive dimensions, while quality toppings and balanced sauce create consistently excellent pizza.
The “Classic Pepperoni” showcases their ability to perfect fundamentals, while specialty combinations like “The Jayhawk” with chicken and bacon appeal to adventurous eaters.
3. Godfather’s Pizza
This Midwestern chain’s Olathe location has distinguished itself through exceptional execution, community involvement, and genuine local character.
Their distinctive thick, golden crust with slightly sweet sauce represents classic Heartland pizza style.
The “Combo” with multiple meats and vegetables delivers hearty satisfaction, while individual-sized pizzas accommodate solo diners.
The family-friendly atmosphere includes arcade games and sports memorabilia, creating a complete entertainment experience.
4. Monk’s Roast Beef & Pizza
This unique locally-owned establishment successfully combines two beloved comfort foods—roast beef sandwiches and pizza—under one roof.
Their thin-crust pies feature a slightly crispy base and generous toppings, with standout options including the “Monk’s Special” with house-roasted beef and horseradish sauce.
The unpretentious setting focuses on quality rather than atmosphere, making Monk’s popular for takeout and casual dine-in meals.
5. Old Shawnee Pizza & Italian Kitchen
Though originating in neighboring Shawnee, this family-owned restaurant’s Olathe location has become a local favorite for traditional, Midwestern-style pizza.
Their distinctive crust—not too thick or thin—provides the perfect balance, while their slightly sweet sauce and generous cheese create classic comfort.
The “Old Shawnee Special” combines traditional toppings for hearty satisfaction, while seasonal specials incorporate local ingredients.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
