Orlando’s food scene isn’t just about world-famous theme parks; it’s a surprisingly rich, diverse, and ever-evolving landscape—especially when it comes to pizza.
Whether you’re after a thick, cheesy slice, a bubbly Neapolitan pie, or creative toppings in a neighborhood hangout, Orlando delivers pizza in every style.
Here are the five best pizza places in Orlando for 2025, representing the cream of the crop for locals and visitors alike.
1. Frank’s Pizza Shop
Frank’s Pizza Shop has firmly established itself as a leader in Orlando’s pizza scene.
Crowned the Critic’s Choice for Best Pizza in the 2025 Orlando Sentinel Foodie Awards, Frank’s is especially beloved for its grandma pie—a rectangular, thick-yet-airy crust topped with a zesty tomato sauce and perfectly melty cheese.
With a focus on traditional techniques and a refusal to cut corners, Frank’s consistently impresses with pies that blend nostalgia with quality.
It’s a true comfort for anyone who loves classic New York and Italian-American pizza elevated with fresh ingredients and expert balance.
2. Flippers Pizzeria
Flippers specializes in brick-oven magic—a hallmark of the Dr. Phillips and other Orlando locations.
Their pizzas are made with all-natural dough, slow-risen and stretched by hand, then topped with everything from simple pepperoni to smoked applewood bacon and roasted garlic.
The resulting pies have bubbly, crisp-edged crusts and a touch of that flame-kissed char so many pizza lovers crave.
Flippers is a local favorite for dine-in, takeout, and family meals, and their diverse menu keeps everyone happy.
3. Camelo Pizzaria
Bringing a taste of Brazil and Europe to Central Florida, Camelo Pizzaria is a standout for artisan pies and fresh, inventive toppings.
They offer everything from classic Margherita and pepperoni to more adventurous pizzas featuring house-made sauces and imported cheeses.
Their dedication to high-quality ingredients and perfect bake shines through in every pie, and Camelo’s delivery reputation means you can enjoy top-tier pizza whether you’re at home or in a nearby hotel.
4. John and John’s A Pizza Shop
John and John’s is a rising gem on Orlando’s Yelp charts, celebrated for its friendly service and innovative specialty pies.
Their hand-tossed dough forms the basis for pizzas loaded with premium toppings like spicy soppressata, hot honey, or fresh basil.
The vibe is welcoming and relaxed, appealing to families and solo diners alike, and their menu balances creative one-offs with comforting standards.
5. NYPD Pizza
For fans of true foldable, New York-style slices, NYPD Pizza delivers authenticity in every bite.
Perfectly thin crusts blister in the oven, melting the cheese over a rich, tangy tomato sauce.
Generous toppings and a commitment to traditional methods have made NYPD Pizza a standby for locals hunting for that classic taste of The Big Apple in Central Florida.
Grab a slice or a whole pie—either way, you’ll see why this pizzeria is an Orlando staple.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
