Pasadena’s pizza scene is as diverse as the city itself, offering everything from authentic Neapolitan pies and classic New York slices to gourmet specialties and locally owned gems.
Whether you seek artisan wood-fired crust, crowd-pleasing classics, or inventive modern options, Pasadena has a slice (or a whole pie) for every craving.
Here are the five best pizza spots in Pasadena for 2025—each celebrated for great flavor, loyal fans, and unique local character.
1. Sapori Di 786 Degrees
Frequently topping the lists of not just Pasadena’s, but California’s best pizzerias, Sapori Di 786 Degrees is renowned for its world-traveling menu and authentic, artisan Neapolitan pies.
Chef Ali Haider’s self-taught mastery shines through pillowy, wood-fired crust, unique international flavor combinations (from Italian to Indian and beyond), and attention to detail.
The passion behind every pie lands Sapori Di 786 Degrees among the nation’s most acclaimed pizza experiences.
2. Settebello Pizzeria Napoletana
Settebello brings the true taste of Naples to Pasadena with its VPN-certified Neapolitan pizzas.
Expect a chewy, slightly charred crust, bright San Marzano tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and top-tier toppings, all baked in a traditional wood-fired oven.
With an elegant yet comfortable setting, Settebello has cemented its place as a go-to for both purists and adventurous eaters seeking authentic Italian pizza.
3. Prince Street Pizza
A celebrated New York transplant, Prince Street Pizza offers up thick, square “Sicilian” slices, tangy sauce, gooey mozzarella, and the legendary spicy pepperoni that “cups and chars.”
With a loyal Instagram following and rave reviews for both its signature squares and classic round pies, Prince Street has quickly become a Pasadena must for slice lovers and those craving a taste of NYC.
4. Pie Life Pizza
Pie Life Pizza embodies the best in laid-back, local California pizzerias.
With a focus on hand-tossed, crispy-edged pies and fresh, flavorful ingredients, Pie Life draws crowds for its classic pepperoni as well as creative seasonal specials.
The friendly setting and great value make it a favorite for families, students, and anyone looking for a casual but top-tier slice.
5. The Kitchen Italian Cafe and Pizzeria
Merging a welcoming Italian cafe with a full-service pizzeria, The Kitchen offers classic thin-crust pies, rich house-made sauces, and an array of authentic toppings in an inviting, homey space.
Their extensive menu and focus on quality ingredients means there’s something for everyone, whether you want a traditional Margherita or a hearty meat-lovers’ creation.
Regulars also rave about their pastas and warm hospitality.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
