Pembroke Pines combines South Florida diversity, family-friendly suburban planning, and year-round outdoor lifestyle in this growing Broward County city.
These five pizzerias represent Pembroke Pines’ best in 2025, each bringing distinctive flavor to local tables.
1. Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza
This South Florida success story’s Pembroke Pines location delivers distinctive “well-done” pizzas from 900-degree coal ovens that create uniquely charred, crisp crusts with chewy interiors.
Their simple, high-quality toppings like imported Italian products and fresh mozzarella shine on this exceptional base.
The “Paul & Young Ron” with meatballs and ricotta has developed a regional following, while their roasted cauliflower pizza demonstrates creative vegetable applications.
2. Pasquale’s Pizza & Subs
This family-owned establishment brings authentic New York-Italian quality to Pembroke Pines with hand-tossed pies featuring thin, foldable crusts and perfect cheese-to-sauce balance.
The “Pines Boulevard Special” combines classic toppings on their excellent foundation, while their Sicilian square pizza offers a thicker alternative that’s achieved local fame.
The welcoming atmosphere reflects genuine family hospitality, creating connections with regular customers across multiple generations.
Beyond pizza, their complete Italian-American menu makes Pasquale’s a versatile dining option.
3. The Pizza Press
This build-your-own concept combines customization with quality through thin-crust personal pizzas with newspaper-themed names.
The “Chronicle” with pepperoni and mushrooms and the “Tribune” with chicken and bacon satisfy traditional tastes, while unlimited custom options accommodate diverse preferences.
The modern, family-friendly space at Pembroke Gardens attracts shoppers and local families alike.
Regular themed events and specials create community engagement beyond typical dining.
4. Mimi’s Ravioli & Pizza
This unique Italian market and pizzeria combination has become a Pembroke Pines institution by offering both exceptional take-home Italian products and excellent pizza.
Their medium-thin crust with slightly sweet sauce and quality cheese creates consistently satisfying pies.
The “Mimi’s Special” features their house-made Italian sausage and fresh vegetables on their well-executed foundation.
5. Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza
This Miami favorite’s Pembroke Pines location brings their innovative star-shaped pizza with stuffed points to a new audience.
Founded by an Italian master pizzaiolo, their distinctive technique creates pockets of ricotta and honey in the crust points surrounding a thin-center pie.
Signature creations like the “Star Luca” with spicy salami and the “Coffee Paolo” with Italian coffee reduction demonstrate their creative approach to traditional Italian pizza.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
