5 Best Pizza Places in Pompano Beach, Florida to Try

Pompano Beach pizza is equal parts beachy laid-back fun, New York–style perfection, and global curiosity.

Here’s where to find the city’s best pies in 2025:

1. Phil’s Heavenly Pizza

Family-owned and faith-inspired, Phil’s serves massive, doughy NY-style pies with a reputation for fresh daily dough and bold, classic toppings.

The “Heavenly Special” (pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers) and white garlic pizza keep families and locals coming back—and slices are loved by beach-goers after a day in the sun.

2. Umberto’s of Long Island

A Broward legend straight from NY, Umberto’s is famed for authentic Sicilian squares, crisp grandma pies, and classic round options with bubbly cheese.

The “Upside-Down Sicilian” is a must, and the friendly staff hustle to run a busy, no-nonsense shop.

3. Rotelli Pizza & Pasta

A Florida-based chain with a great local presence, Rotelli brings the Italian-American touch, from “Meat Lover’s Calzone” to pepperoni-stuffed crust.

Their “Pompano Special” pizza and margherita are favorites, and the robust pasta and salad menu—plus wine—make it a comfortable, crowd-friendly choice.

4. Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza

Anthony’s brings Northeast tradition to South Florida, with a coal oven yielding blistered crust, signature “well-done” bites, and toppings like coal-roasted chicken, spicy sausage, and roasted cauliflower.

Try the “Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pie” for a regional kick, and finish with their famous wings.

5. Pizza Machine

A local pizzeria known for party-sized pies and speedy delivery, Pizza Machine is a go-to for weekend gatherings, game nights, or casual beach dining.

Pies are big, cheesy, and loaded; the “BBQ Chicken” and “Veggie Lovers” have loyal followings. Subs, pasta, and wings round out the classic menu.