5 Best Pizza Places in Port St. Lucie to Try

Port St. Lucie combines Florida’s relaxed coastal lifestyle with growing suburban communities in this expanding Treasure Coast city.

From New York transplants to creative local spots, these five pizzerias represent Port St. Lucie’s best in 2025.

1. Tutto Fresco

This family-owned establishment brings authentic New York-Italian quality to Port St. Lucie with hand-tossed pies featuring thin, foldable crusts and perfect cheese-to-sauce balance.

The “Tutto Special” combines classic toppings on their excellent foundation, while their Sicilian square pizza offers a thicker alternative that’s achieved local fame.

The welcoming atmosphere reflects the family’s genuine hospitality, creating connections with regular customers that extend beyond typical restaurant service.

2. West End Pizza

Located in Tradition, West End Pizza combines wood-fired artisan techniques with family-friendly accessibility.

Their distinctive oven produces thin crusts with perfect char and chewiness, while thoughtfully selected toppings create balanced flavor combinations.

The “Tradition” with prosciutto and arugula has become a neighborhood favorite, while the “Treasure Coast” incorporates local seafood and citrus notes.

3. Italian Cousin Pizzeria

This authentic neighborhood spot delivers classic New York-style pizza from transplanted Staten Island owners who brought their family recipes to Florida.

Their thin-crust pies with slightly sweet sauce and quality cheese satisfy the many Northeastern transplants in Port St. Lucie, while local adaptations like the “St. Lucie River” with fresh seafood embrace their new Florida home.

4. Maxx’s Famiglia Pizzeria

Serving eastern Port St. Lucie, Maxx’s delivers reliable, family-style pizza with a medium-thick crust and generous toppings.

Their “PSL Special” combines pepperoni, sausage, and vegetables on their well-executed foundation, while specialty options like the “Mets Pizza” (named for the baseball team that holds spring training nearby) with blue and orange ingredients demonstrate local connections.

5. Florida Craft Pizza & Beer

This innovative spot combines artisanal pizza with Florida’s craft beer scene, creating a destination for both quality pies and exceptional beverages.

Their naturally leavened sourdough crust develops complex flavor through long fermentation, while creative toppings showcase Florida ingredients like datil peppers and local produce.

The “PGA Village” (named for the nearby golf community) with goat cheese and fig jam appeals to sophisticated palates, while classic options satisfy traditional preferences.