Rochester’s pizza landscape is both fiercely local and wonderfully eclectic. Named the nation’s best pizza city in 2025—with one of the highest “pizza passion” scores, a surge of independent pizzerias, and signature Western New York style—Rochester offers classic comfort, creative innovation, and top-tier quality at every turn.
Thick, chewy crusts with “cup-and-char” pepperoni, Detroit-style slabs, and New York–inspired slices mingle in a scene as vibrant as the city itself.
Here are the five best pizza spots in Rochester for 2025, each beloved in the local community and recognized beyond it.
1. Pizza Wizard
A rising star in Rochester’s gourmet pizza scene, Pizza Wizard wins over fans with creative pies featuring high-quality, thoughtfully sourced ingredients and inventive combinations.
From wood-fired crusts to unique topping pairings, it’s the go-to for pizza lovers seeking bold flavor and a playful, hip vibe.
The attention to craft and detail keeps both locals and visitors returning for more.
2. The Pizza Stop
With roots deep in classic New York pizzeria tradition, The Pizza Stop is all about thin, foldable slices and hand-tossed crust.
Known for their consistency, speedy counter service, and no-nonsense retro style, this is where you’ll find Rochester’s perfect NY-style cheese or pepperoni slice—done right, every time.
A staple for both lunch breaks and late-night cravings.
3. Mark’s Pizzeria
A regional favorite since 1982, Mark’s Pizzeria has built a reputation on fresh, never frozen dough, flavorful sauce, and stellar delivery.
The menu blends Western New York style (thicker, chewy crust, cupped pepperoni) with crowd-pleasing specialty pies and family deals.
Mark’s offers convenience without sacrificing quality—ideal for parties, takeout, or an easy night in.
4. Fiorella
Located at the Public Market, Fiorella takes pizza up a notch with its rustic Italian wood-fired approach.
Expect blistered, airy crusts topped with local produce, artisan meats, and imported cheeses.
The inviting ambiance and creative seasonal toppings—plus rave reviews from diner ratings—make it a must for pizza purists and foodies craving a special night out.
5. GG’s Pizza
Blending classic pizzeria fare with specialty pies, GG’s Pizza is a beloved neighborhood spot.
Known for its balanced crust (not too thick, not too thin), generous cheese, and distinctive “cup-and-char” pepperoni, GG’s delivers that iconic Western New York flavor.
It’s laid-back, reliably delicious, and perfect for takeout with family or friends.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
