5 Best Pizza Places in Simi Valley, California to Try

Simi Valley’s pizza scene is a flavorful mix of family-owned institutions, classic Italian-American comfort, and fresh local favorites.

Whether you crave a gooey New York–style slice, an old-school Sicilian, or creative gourmet toppings, these pizzerias deliver the city’s best pies with trademark SoCal hospitality.

Here are the five best pizza places in Simi Valley for 2025, all earning loyal followings for their quality, service, and community spirit.

1. Tomato Pie Pizza Joint

A standout for authentic New York–style pizza, Tomato Pie Pizza Joint serves up large, thin, foldable slices with just the right balance of sauce, cheese, and crispness.

The menu features classics (try the Pepperoni or White Pie) plus creative options and Italian-American favorites.

Fast, friendly service and a local, laid-back vibe make Tomato Pie a go-to for families and slice lovers alike.

2. Chi-Chi’s Pizza

A Simi Valley institution since the 1950s, Chi-Chi’s is famed for its hearty, thick-crust pies, rich tomato sauce, and mountains of mozzarella.

With a retro dining room full of family energy, Chi-Chi’s is perfect for celebrations and comfort food cravings.

The “Special” loaded with sausage, pepperoni, and veggies is a must—plus, don’t miss their iconic garlic bread and salads.

3. Ameci Pizza & Pasta

Ameci’s combines value, speed, and variety—serving up thin-crust, NY-style pizzas and a huge menu of Italian dishes, subs, and salads.

Beloved for its reliable delivery, savory sauce, crispy-yet-chewy crusts, and generous toppings, Ameci is a local favorite for group orders, parties, or a relaxed pizza night at home.

The “Meat Lovers” and “Ameci Special” pies are local hits.

4. D’Amore’s Pizza

Well-known in the LA area, D’Amore’s brings East Coast flair and extra-fresh ingredients to Simi Valley.

Their signature is a crispy, thin, brick oven–baked crust topped with sweet tomato sauce, stretchy cheese, and specialty toppings like arugula, prosciutto, or spicy sausage.

The “D’Amore Special” and Margarita pie are favorites for both takeout and dine-in.

5. Presto Pasta

While Presto Pasta is best known for fast-casual Italian plates, their hand-tossed pizzas have built a quiet cult following.

Expect perfectly baked crust, flavorful sauce, and popular combos like Margherita, Veggie, or Chicken Pesto.

Paired with their signature garlic knots or a fresh salad, Presto Pasta’s pizzas hit the spot for quick dinners and family meals.