5 Best Pizza Places in Stillwater, Oklahoma to Try

Stillwater combines Oklahoma State University energy, genuine prairie hospitality, and surprising culinary depth.

Here’s where locals find their favorite pizza in 2025.

1. Hideaway Pizza

This Oklahoma institution’s Stillwater location (one of their original spots!) delivers distinctive pies that generations of OSU students and locals consider essential to the college experience.

Their slightly sweet sauce and perfect crust with just the right chew create that nostalgic flavor that’s fueled countless study sessions and game day celebrations since the 1950s.

The walls covered with decades of university memorabilia create a museum-like chronicle of OSU history.

2. The Union Pizza & Public House

This downtown favorite fires artisanal pies in a beautiful brick oven within a renovated historic building that contributes to Stillwater’s ongoing renaissance.

Their naturally leavened dough develops complex flavor through extended fermentation, while seasonal ingredients from nearby farms create distinctive combinations that change regularly.

The “Cowboy” featuring local beef and vegetables celebrates regional connections, while their craft beer selection showcases Oklahoma breweries.

3. Brooklyn’s Wood Fired Pizza

This upscale casual concept brings Neapolitan-inspired techniques to Stillwater with imported equipment and rigorous attention to authentic methods.

Their light, airy crusts with perfect leopard spotting support both traditional combinations and creative offerings featuring seasonal Oklahoma ingredients.

The elegant yet approachable atmosphere makes this suitable for special occasions while still welcoming students.

4. College Gardens Pizza & Subs

This campus-adjacent favorite delivers consistent quality with that perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings that defines college-town comfort pizza.

Their hand-tossed pies feature generous toppings at student-friendly prices, making this a practical option for tight budgets.

Nothing fancy here – just reliable pizza that satisfies late-night cravings without complication.

5. Prairie Fire Pizza Truck

This mobile wood-fired operation brings exceptional pizza to OSU events, breweries, and festivals throughout Stillwater.

Their portable Italian oven creates perfectly charred crusts topped with creative combinations that showcase Oklahoma ingredients.

The “Stillwater Farmers Market” featuring seasonal produce changes weekly based on what’s available locally.

Social media followers track their location religiously, creating a community of devoted fans who appreciate quality pizza in unexpected locations.