Suffolk’s pizza mirrors its unique blend of rural comforts, coastal flavors, and small-city hospitality.
Whether you love local classics, gourmet pies, or Southern-style twists, here are Suffolk’s top five pizzerias in 2025:
1. Amici’s Pizza Café
Downtown’s go-to, Amici’s is famous for brick-oven pies, housemade sauce, and a huge range of both classic and specialty pizzas.
With a welcoming bistro vibe, Amici’s serves the “Amici’s Special” (peppers, onions, mushrooms, sausage, pepperoni) and a rich, garlicky White Pizza.
The pastas and salads are equally beloved, making it perfect for families and date nights.
2. Mod Pizza
For fast, fully customizable pies, Mod’s build-your-own setup is unmatched. Thin, crisp crusts, unlimited toppings, gluten-free options, and affordable prices have made Mod a hit with students and busy families.
Quick, friendly, and ideal for picky eaters.
3. Derl’z Restaurant & Pub
A Suffolk staple, Derl’z makes hearty, cheesy pizzas with classic and fun specialty toppings (jalapeños, barbecue chicken, shrimp).
Their “Derl’z Deluxe” is loaded, and the rustic pub setting is popular for both lunch and game nights.
Southern hospitality and big portions define the experience.
4. Sal’s Pizza
Sal’s is Suffolk’s old-school favorite, winning rave reviews for classic NY-style pizza, authentic sauces, and Sicilian options.
Their hot subs, calzones, and stromboli are standout, and the “Meat Lovers” and “Spinach Alfredo” pies get top billing.
Friendly staff and fast takeout make it a loyal local favorite.
5. Marco’s Pizza
Known for reliable delivery, thick and thin crusts, and crowd-pleasing specialties, Marco’s is a mainstay.
The “White Cheezy” and “Deluxe” are especially popular, and their cheesy breadsticks and salads are beloved sides.
It’s a go-to for quick family meals and pizza parties.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
