Tracy’s pizza scene blends Bay Area energy, agricultural abundance, and small-town warmth, offering everything from hearty classics to inventive artisan fare.
Here are Tracy’s five most beloved pizzerias in 2025:
1. Magellan’s Restaurant
Magellan’s is a downtown Tracy institution, famous for its brick-oven pizzas with chewy, flavorful crusts.
They use local produce, house-made sauce, and a wide variety of toppings, both traditional and creative.
The “Magellan’s Supreme,” loaded with meats and veggies, and the “Pear & Prosciutto” pie showcase their range.
Their rustic dining room and craft beer selection make this the spot for both family gatherings and date nights.
2. Famous Pizza Tracy
A no-frills classic serving the city for decades, Famous Pizza Tracy is beloved for its crisp, golden crust, generous cheese, and speedy service.
Slices are big and New York–style: foldable, cheesy, and perfect for takeout or sharing. The “Meat Lovers” and “Combo” pies are especially popular.
Their late hours and fair prices make this a hit with students and families on the go.
3. Pizza Guys
Part of a successful Northern California chain, Pizza Guys in Tracy shines with its flavorful hand-tossed crust, a range of sauces, and innovative specialty pies.
The “Texas BBQ” with chicken and red onions, and “Garlic Chicken & Bacon” always win rave reviews.
They offer gluten-free and cauliflower crusts, curbside pickup, and plenty of deals for family nights.
4. Slices Downtown
A local favorite for gourmet slices and whole pies, Slices Downtown specializes in using premium ingredients and lots of vegetarian or vegan options.
From the classic “Pepperoni” to the “White Pie” with ricotta and garlic, you’ll find trendy flavors alongside traditional offerings.
The chill atmosphere, specialty sodas, and fun mural-filled space make it a cool hangout.
5. Straw Hat Pizza
A California-born chain with deep Tracy roots, Straw Hat delivers classic, pan-style pizza that’s both cheesy and satisfying.
The “Straw Hat Special” is loaded with all the meats and veggies, while their “Hot Hat” sandwiches and salad bar keep things interesting.
Arcade games and a party-friendly setting make Straw Hat a hit for kids and group events.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
