Tyler’s pizza scene is a reflection of East Texas’s welcoming spirit and love of big portions, bold flavors, and down-home hospitality.
Whether you’re after old-school comfort, inventive artisan pies, or a quick slice before a show, these five pizzerias top the Tyler pizza charts for 2025.
1. Villaggio del Vino
A more upscale experience, Villaggio del Vino brings a slice of Italy to Tyler’s south side.
Their wood-fired oven turns out bubbly, lightly charred crusts topped with premium ingredients: fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, arugula, and imported San Marzano tomato sauce.
The “Diavola” (spicy salami, honey, red pepper flakes) and the white pie with mushrooms and truffle oil are city favorites.
The wine list is one of the best in town, and their cozy patio is ideal for date nights or leisurely family meals.
2. Rounder’s Pizza
For classic, American-style hand-tossed pizza, Rounder’s is a Tyler institution.
Since the 1990s, families and college students have flocked for their super-cheesy pies, friendly small-town staff, and loaded “Rounder’s Special” (pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers).
Don’t miss the buttery garlic breadsticks, and expect a bustling atmosphere, especially on weekends and game nights.
3. Newk’s Eatery
While not just a pizzeria, Newk’s in Tyler has gained a following for its crisp, thin-crust artisan pizzas.
The “Spicy Sicilian” and “Margherita” pies get high marks, with fresh basil, Roma tomatoes, cured meats, and a just-sweet-enough marinara.
Their fast-casual approach and huge salads make it a top pick for workday lunches and family takeout.
4. Ken’s Pizza
For those seeking nostalgia and great value, Ken’s Pizza has been serving Tyler for decades with thin, classic crust loaded right to the edge and crisped to perfection.
The “Ken’s Combo” and taco pizza are favorites among longtime locals, and the lunch buffet is a rite of passage for generations.
Retro booths and quick counter service create true small-town charm.
5. Papacita’s Mexican Restaurant
Yes, you read that correctly—some of the most inventive pies in Tyler are coming out of a beloved Tex-Mex joint.
Their “Tex-Mex Pizza” fuses classic pizza with taco toppings, jalapeños, and seasoned beef, perfect for anyone who loves a twist.
Big portions and a crowd-pleasing, family-friendly energy make Papacita’s a fun, unique pick.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
