5 Best Pizza Places in Waterbury, Connecticut to Try

Waterbury, Connecticut, sits in the shadow of New Haven’s pizza fame, but this spirited Naugatuck Valley city has a pizza scene all its own.

Waterbury’s best pizzerias reflect Italian-American heritage, loyal local followings, and a love for both classic and inventive pies.

Whether you’re searching for crispy bar pies, Neapolitan perfection, or hearty, cheese-loaded slices, check out these five pizza gems—widely considered the top in Waterbury for 2025.

1. Domenick & Pia Downtown Pizzeria

A Waterbury landmark since 1967, Domenick & Pia is a must for classic, foldable “Connecticut-style” pies with thin, crisp crust, zesty sauce, and fresh mozzarella.

Slices are legendary for their simplicity and balance—no frills, just perfect execution.

The old-school vibe and bustling lunch rush have made it a city staple for generations, and locals insist there’s no better cheese or pepperoni pie anywhere in town.

2. Big Frank’s Pizza

Beloved for both its ample portions and creative toppings, Big Frank’s consistently ranks among Waterbury’s best.

Their large, cheesy pies are perfect for feeding families and parties, with fans raving about their tangy tomato sauce, fluffy-yet-crispy crusts, and loaded meat and veggie combos.

Try the “House Special” for the ultimate sample of Frank’s signature flavors.

3. Vineria Pizza

For authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, Vineria Pizza stands out with its wood-fired, charred, airy crusts and fresh imported ingredients.

The Margherita and Diavola are crowd-pleasers, and rotating chef’s specials highlight seasonal, gourmet toppings.

A warm, modern dining room and a well-curated wine list make Vineria a favorite for date nights and Italian food aficionados.

4. Frankie’s Pizza

A no-nonsense spot beloved for fast service, big flavor, and affordable prices, Frankie’s Pizza serves up hefty slices and whole pies with plenty of cheese and sauce.

The “Meat Lovers” and “Buffalo Chicken” pies are top sellers, but even a plain cheese slice wins fans for its nostalgic charm and generous portions. The laid-back, family atmosphere is perfect for a casual dinner or takeout.

5. Nardelli’s Grinder Shoppe & Pizza

Known primarily for their famous grinders, Nardelli’s also offers a surprisingly delicious pizza menu.

Their dough is chewy and flavorful, topped edge-to-edge with rich sauce and plenty of cheese.

Specialty options like “Italian Stallion” (sausage, peppers, onions) and the classic veggie pie round out a menu that keeps Nardelli’s packed with regulars, whether you’re in for a grinder, a slice, or both.