5 Best Pizza Places in West Covina, California to Try

West Covina blends SoCal suburban comfort, diverse communities, and San Gabriel Valley flavor.

Here’s where locals are finding the best pizza in 2025.

1. Petrillo’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant

This West Covina institution (since 1954!) still makes their pies the same way they did when Eisenhower was president – hand-tossed dough, slightly sweet sauce, and generous toppings that generations of locals consider the gold standard.

The vintage dining room with red vinyl booths creates time-travel vibes, while the owners still work the counter most days.

2. SGV Pizza Lab

This innovative spot brings San Gabriel Valley’s amazing Asian flavors to pizza with combinations that shouldn’t work but absolutely do.

Their crispy-bottom crust gets topped with creative fusion like the “Taiwanese Night Market” with five-spice pork belly and the “K-Town” with bulgogi and kimchi.

3. Bronco’s Pizza

This neighborhood joint near the high school has fueled post-game celebrations and study sessions for decades with consistent quality and generous toppings at prices that respect West Covina’s working families.

Nothing fancy here – just reliable pizza with the perfect amount of grease that somehow tastes even better the next morning.

4. Settebello Pizzeria Napoletana

This upscale concept brings certified Neapolitan pizza to the suburbs with imported Italian equipment and rigorous technique.

Their light, airy crusts with perfect leopard spotting support traditional combinations that follow strict Italian guidelines.

The elegant yet approachable atmosphere makes this suitable for date nights and special occasions, while still welcoming families.

5. Viva Madrid Pizza & Tapas

This unique concept successfully combines Spanish flavors with pizza techniques in a lively atmosphere that’s become a local favorite for gatherings.

Their thin, crispy crust serves as the canvas for creative combinations like the “Flamenco” with chorizo and manchego and the “Valencia” with seafood inspired by paella.