5 Best Pizza Places in Wilmington, North Carolina to Try

Wilmington, NC, offers a lively mix of beach-town energy, historic charm, and a food scene that’s quickly gaining regional buzz.

The city’s pizzerias reflect that spirit—balancing classic comfort, creative coastal flair, and New York nostalgia.

Whether you crave wood-fired Neapolitan, jumbo slices, or inventive specialty pies, these five spots define pizza in Wilmington for 2025.

1. Slice of Life Pizzeria & Pub

An icon in downtown Wilmington, Slice of Life serves till the wee hours and is equally beloved by locals and late-night visitors.

Their NY-style pies are big, cheesy, and perfectly foldable.

The menu features classics (plain cheese or pepperoni always satisfy), gourmet toppings, and even whole-wheat crust options.

With a casual, bustling vibe and a reputation for friendly service, Slice of Life is a go-to for a night out or quick slice after the beach.

2. PT’s Olde Fashioned Grille & Pizza

While famous for their burgers, PT’s has quietly built a cult following for their hand-tossed pizzas.

Try the Supreme or BBQ Chicken Pizza for a Southern twist on classic combinations.

Their house-made dough and tangy sauce set them apart, as does the option to enjoy your pie on their laid-back patio, perfect for Wilmington’s temperate evenings.

3. Michaelangelo’s Pizza & Subs

For the ultimate East Coast slice, Michaelangelo’s delivers with crispy, thin crusts and a classic cheese-to-sauce ratio.

Subs, stromboli, and wings round out the enormous menu, but it’s the pizza—especially the Sicilian and specialty white pies—that keeps both students and families coming back.

Their multiple locations across the city make this a reliable Wilmington favorite.

4. Mellow Mushroom

Part of a beloved regional chain, Mellow Mushroom brings Southern hospitality, funky décor, and stone-baked pies to Wilmington.

Signature offerings like the “Holy Shiitake” and “Mighty Meaty” pair with house-made dough and a robust beer list.

Vegan and gluten-free options make this a hit with college students and families alike.

5. Pizzeria Il Forno

For authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, Pizzeria Il Forno is Wilmington’s artisan standout.

Using imported Caputo flour, fresh mozzarella, and a wood-fired oven, Il Forno’s blistered, chewy crusts and minimalist toppings win critical raves.

Try the Margherita or the spicy Diavola, and enjoy a glass of wine in their rustic, intimate dining room—a perfect spot for foodies and date nights.