Winston-Salem’s pizza scene marries Southern hospitality with cosmopolitan flavor, offering everything from rustic Neapolitan pies and NY-style slices to inventive, chef-driven creations.
Whether you’re a purist or a pizza adventurer, these five pizzerias are celebrated for quality, consistency, and a devoted local following.
1. Cugino Forno
Widely regarded as the gold standard for Neapolitan pizza in the Triad, Cugino Forno crafts wood-fired pies using imported Italian ingredients and time-honored techniques.
Expect a lightly charred, pillowy crust, San Marzano tomato sauce, and fresh mozzarella on every order.
The classic Margherita is a staple, but meat lovers and vegetarians alike rave about the creative specials, all served in a relaxed but stylish setting.
2. Mellow Mushroom
Part of a beloved regional chain, Mellow Mushroom offers a funky, fun atmosphere and hand-tossed pies piled high with imaginative toppings.
Their signature stone-baked crust comes with plenty of creative and vegan-friendly choices, along with craft beers and signature cocktails.
The Holy Shiitake and Kosmic Karma pizzas keep both locals and students coming back for more.
3. Mario’s Pizza
For those craving classic New York–style slices or giant Sicilian squares, Mario’s is the local go-to.
With a focus on large, foldable slices, hearty portions, and an extensive menu (calzones, pasta, and heroes included), Mario’s keeps families and longtime Winston-Salem residents satisfied.
Their consistent quality, quick service, and generous toppings make Mario’s a regular stop for pizza night.
4. King’s Hot Dogs & Pizza
A hidden gem for Winston-Salem locals, King’s Hot Dogs & Pizza serves up crowd-pleasing thin-crust pizzas with tasty sauce, plenty of gooey cheese, and customizable toppings.
In addition to pizza, their menu boasts all-American classics like burgers, dogs, and fries—making it a go-to for casual family meals.
Fast, friendly service and affordable lunch specials have earned King’s a place on every local’s list.
5. Donato’s Pizza
Donato’s brings the best of Ohio-style thin crust to Winston-Salem: edge-to-edge toppings, a signature crispy base, and crowd-pleasing specialty pies.
Their lean pepperoni, veggie-heavy options, and gluten-free crusts appeal to a wide audience, and the efficient delivery service is a plus for busy families and college students.
Their commitment to quality ingredients and loaded pies makes Donato’s a popular pick.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
