5 Underrated Lakeland, Florida Restaurants that Are Absolutely Worth Trying

Situated between Tampa and Orlando, Lakeland is a Central Florida city known for its stunning collection of Frank Lloyd Wright architecture and its many picturesque lakes.

Its food scene is a reflection of its unique character—a blend of old Florida charm and a growing contemporary energy.

While new restaurants are always popping up, the city’s most beloved spots are often the ones that have been serving the community for years, or the newer places that champion local flavor.

Here are five underrated restaurants that capture the true taste of Lakeland.

1. Black & Brew Coffee House & Bistro

Much more than just a coffee shop, Black & Brew is the unofficial living room of downtown Lakeland.

This bustling bistro serves creative sandwiches, fresh salads, and comforting soups, all made with a chef’s touch. With two downtown locations, it’s a hub of community activity from morning to night. Their seasonal menu and delicious baked goods make it a place you’ll want to return to again and again.

2. Nineteen61

Bringing upscale, modern Latin American cuisine to Lakeland, Nineteen61 is a fine-dining experience that would be at home in any major city.

The chef artfully blends his Peruvian heritage with global influences, creating dishes that are both innovative and deeply flavorful.

From stunning ceviches to perfectly cooked steaks, it’s a celebration of bold flavors in an elegant, contemporary setting.

3. Palace Pizza

For a perfect slice of New York-style pizza, Palace Pizza is a Lakeland institution.

This casual, counter-service spot in the heart of downtown has been serving up huge, foldable slices and whole pies to a loyal following for over 20 years. It’s a simple, no-frills place that focuses on getting the essentials right: a thin, crisp crust, quality cheese, and flavorful sauce.

4. The Red Top Pit Stop

A bit of a drive from the city center, The Red Top Pit Stop is a classic, old-school barbecue joint that’s well worth the journey.

This cash-only, walk-up window spot serves up incredible slow-smoked meats, from tender sliced pork to juicy ribs. It’s a true taste of old Florida, with a focus on simple, delicious BBQ and friendly service that has made it a local legend.

5. Born & Bread Bakehouse

While technically a bakery, the weekend crowds and cult-like following make Born & Bread an essential part of Lakeland’s food scene.

Open only on weekends, they produce some of the best croissants, cruffins (a croissant-muffin hybrid), and artisan bread in the state. The line often snakes around the block before they even open, a testament to the incredible quality and creativity of their baked goods.