Atlanta’s pizza scene is delightfully diverse, serving everything from authentic Neapolitan pies to massive New York-style slices and creative, Southern-inspired favorites.
Whether you’re a crust connoisseur or someone who just loves gooey cheese, the city has a world-class pizza for every craving.
Here are the top five pizza places you must try in Atlanta:
1. Antico Pizza Napoletana
Why it’s Great:
Antico is widely regarded as Atlanta’s gold standard for Neapolitan pizza.
Their signature approach involves baking pies at blazingly high heat in imported Italian ovens, resulting in a soft, chewy crust with perfect char and luscious toppings.
Favorites like the Margherita D.O.P. and the spicy Diavola feature fresh mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, and premium cured meats.
The lively, communal atmosphere adds to the authentic Italian experience.
2. Varasano’s Pizzeria
Why it’s Great:
Famous for its meticulously fermented, thin, yet chewy crust, Varasano’s is a go-to for pizza purists and those craving true Neapolitan style.
Only one pizza size is offered—a testament to their confidence in quality and time-tested recipes.
Their combinations, like tomato, mozzarella, and fresh herbs, shine through, and the location even serves up stellar pies at Hartsfield-Jackson Airport, making it a must for both locals and travelers.
3. Fellini’s Pizza
Why it’s Great:
For over 40 years, Fellini’s has been beloved for its classic, generous New York-style slices and laid-back Atlanta vibe.
Their pizza is slightly thicker than true NY style, with a pillowy crust, flavorful sauce, and heaping cheese.
Open late with several locations, Fellini’s offers both whole pies and slices—the best option for a casual bite after a night out or a family dinner.
4. Mellow Mushroom
Why it’s Great:
Born right in Atlanta, Mellow Mushroom has grown into a Southern institution thanks to its unique, airy crust and imaginative toppings.
The chain’s downtown location feels funky and artsy, and the pizza menu features everything from classic cheese to pies loaded with pesto, sun-dried tomatoes, multiple cheeses, and vegan or gluten-free options.
It’s a favorite for groups who love lots of choices and a fun, casual setting.
5. Nancy’s Pizza
Why it’s Great:
If you crave authentic Chicago-style deep dish, Nancy’s is the place.
This pizzeria specializes in thick, buttery crusts filled with layers of cheese, savory sauce, and gourmet toppings.
The signature stuffed pizza is legendary—bring your appetite, because slices are hefty!
It’s the top pick for anyone looking to indulge in serious comfort food, Atlanta-style.
| Pizzeria | Style | Signature Pies | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Antico Pizza Napoletana | Neapolitan | Margherita, Diavola | Authentic Italian |
| Varasano’s Pizzeria | Neapolitan/Thin Crust | Classic Tomato, Mozzarella | Pizza aficionados |
| Fellini’s Pizza | NY-style/Atlanta twist | Cheese, Pepperoni, Veggie | Slices, late-night eats |
| Mellow Mushroom | Eclectic/thick crust | Mighty Meaty, Veg Out | Group outings, variety |
| Nancy’s Pizza | Chicago Deep Dish | Stuffed Cheese/Meat Lovers | Indulgent meals |
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
