5 Best Pizza Places in Nashville to Try Today

Nashville’s pizza scene runs deep, uniting classic New York-style slices, authentic Neapolitan pies, and creative Southern twists—all while capturing the city’s signature hospitality and vibrant energy.

Pizza-lovers will find everything from late-night slice joints in buzzing neighborhoods to intimate bistros bringing true Italian craftsmanship to Music City.

Here are the top five pizza spots in Nashville for 2025, each winning over both locals and visitors with distinctive flavors and top-quality pies.

1. Five Points Pizza

A revered East and West Nashville staple, Five Points Pizza is known citywide for authentic New York–style pies, hand-tossed and baked to crispy perfection.

Their scratch-made dough, tangy hand-crushed plum tomato sauce, and shredded or fresh mozzarella set a high bar.

Five Points boasts a creative specialty pie lineup—like the “Zeus” (pepperoni, spicy capicola, black olives, banana peppers, red onions, and feta) or the T-Rex meat lover’s pizza—as well as vegan options.

Slices are served late, and their 16 rotating taps of local and craft beer make this a top destination for pizza and good vibes.

2. Bella Napoli Pizzeria

Italian-owned and run, Bella Napoli brings true Neapolitan tradition to Nashville’s Edgehill Village.

Wood-fired pies feature pillowy, slightly charred crusts, San Marzano tomato sauce, fresh basil, and imported cheeses.

Guests rave about the authentic flavors, warm service, cozy indoor/outdoor seating, and a menu of pastas, antipasti, and Italian cocktails.

Favorites include classic Margherita, Capricciosa, and specialty pies, making Bella Napoli a leading spot for a true Italian experience in the heart of the city.

3. Il Forno

Helmed by a Naples-born chef, Il Forno delivers what many locals—and Italians—consider the best Neapolitan pizza in Nashville.

Dough is naturally leavened and baked in a brutal Napoli oven at blistering heat, producing an airy, generously bubbled crust.

Toppings range from Margherita to inventive specialties, and homemade pastas, classic desserts (tiramisu, panna cotta), and strong espresso round out the experience.

Regulars praise Il Forno’s authenticity and the hospitality of the chef-owner, making it a destination for true pizza connoisseurs.

4. The Stillery

While famous for Southern comfort food and signature mason jar cocktails, The Stillery also impresses with its brick oven pizzas.

Their pies come loaded with creative toppings and local ingredients—fans frequently recommend the “Hot Chicken” pizza as a Nashville-style original.

The welcoming downtown atmosphere, open kitchen, and strong drink menu make this a popular pre-show or night-out stop.

5. NY Pie

NY Pie offers Music City another take on classic New York–style pizza. Pies feature thin, foldable crusts with bubbly edges and a nice chew, loaded with generous sauce and cheese.

With a menu packed with classic toppings and simple specialty pies, NY Pie is beloved by fans originally from up north and anyone craving an unpretentious, top-quality slice.

Their quick service, crispy crust, and grab-and-go vibe earn strong reviews.