5 Best Pizza Places in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania to Try

Pittsburgh’s pizza scene offers a distinct blend of classic Italian-American pizzerias, inventive newcomers, and signature Steel City styles.

From wood-fired ovens to iconic thick crusts, the city’s best pizza joints each boast a loyal following and bring something undeniably Pittsburgh to every pie.

Here are the five best pizza places in Pittsburgh for 2025, offering a delicious taste of what makes the city’s pizza culture so unique.

1. Proper Brick Oven and Tap Room

With a 4.5 rating from over 700 reviews, Proper Brick Oven and Tap Room consistently ranks as the top pizza destination in Pittsburgh.

Located downtown, it’s famed for its chewy, blistered, wood-fired crusts, creative toppings (like arugula and Bianca pizza), and a sophisticated yet relaxed atmosphere.

Their variety of Italian-inspired specialty pies and robust craft beer selection make Proper a must-try for both pizza aficionados and casual diners alike.

2. Pizzaiolo Primo Market Square

Combining authentic Italian recipes with a prime Market Square setting, Pizzaiolo Primo is celebrated for both its classic Neapolitan pizzas and ambiance.

Their scratch-made dough, imported ingredients, and expert technique deliver genuine Italian flavors—especially praised are the Margherita and seafood-topped specials.

Great pasta and desserts complement the pizza, making Pizzaiolo Primo a go-to for date nights and special occasions.

3. Piccolo Forno

Chic and casual, Piccolo Forno specializes in rustic, thin-crust Italian pizza cooked to crispy perfection in Lawrenceville.

Locals love the balance of char, chewy crust, and thoughtfully selected toppings; veggie options and traditional Italian soups add to its broad appeal.

Its stylish atmosphere, attentive service, and consistently delicious pies make it a top Pittsburgh favorite year after year.

4. Mineo’s Pizza House

A Pittsburgh legend, Mineo’s Pizza House serves up classic, hearty pies with a signature thick, golden crust, deeply flavorful sauce, and gooey cheese.

Generous slices and nostalgic charm define the Mineo’s experience—many say it’s the best in the city for those who crave a robust and satisfying traditional slice.

The consistently fresh, cheesy pies have made Mineo’s a must-visit for locals and visitors since its founding.

5. Iron Born Pizza

Iron Born Pizza is the city’s go-to for Detroit-style deep-dish, featuring a light, airy, and crisped-edge crust that stands out from its Thin-crust Pittsburgh peers.

With inventive toppings and a modern kitchen, Iron Born is praised for flavor-forward choices and specialty pies that push Pizza’s creative boundaries—perfect for anyone looking to try something a little different in Pittsburgh.