Lexington’s pizza scene combines classic American comfort, creative Southern influence, and a strong independent spirit.
From gourmet wood-fired pies and NY-style slices to beloved local staples and innovative toppings, these five pizzerias stand out as the best in Lexington for 2025 thanks to their quality, uniqueness, and loyal fanbases.
1. Pazzo’s Pizza Pub
A University of Kentucky favorite, Pazzo’s is famed for its broad menu of hand-tossed pizzas, by-the-slice options, and a lively pub atmosphere stacked with local craft brews.
Their dough is made fresh daily, the topping combos range from classic to wild, and the “Pazzo’s Special” (loaded with meats and veggies) is a local legend.
Perfect for gatherings, game nights, or a casual bite in the heart of campus life.
2. Goodfellas Pizzeria
Goodfellas’ massive, thin NY-style slices and 22-inch pies have won the hearts (and late-night appetites) of Lexington.
Enjoy classic or gourmet toppings, garlic knots, stromboli, and a retro speakeasy bar hidden in the back.
The fun, urban vibe and commitment to authentic, foldable slices make Goodfellas essential for pizza lovers downtown.
3. Pies & Pints
Pies & Pints offers a creative take: hand-tossed, stone-baked pizzas with inventive toppings (like Grape & Gorgonzola or Sriracha Shrimp) and an impressive craft beer list.
Located in the heart of Chevy Chase, their wide range of pizzas—from traditional to bold—comes with a laid-back, cheerful setting perfect for group dining. The “Steak & Mushroom” and “Street Corn” pizzas keep fans talking.
4. Rolling Oven
Starting as a food truck and now a brick-and-mortar staple, Rolling Oven delivers wood-fired pies with bubbly charred crusts and fresh, top-tier ingredients.
Signature picks include the “Buffalo Chicken” and the “Pig & Fig,” and their rotating specials feature seasonal, local produce.
Rolling Oven’s modern Kentucky flair and diverse tap list have built a devoted following.
5. Joe Bologna’s
A Lexington institution since 1973, Joe Bologna’s serves classic, thick-crust Italian-American pizzas in a repurposed historic church.
With its iconic breadsticks, family-friendly vibe, and generous portions, Joe Bologna’s is nostalgia, comfort, and value all in one.
The “Deluxe” pie, loaded with meats and veggies, and the signature Sicilian crust are must-tries for first-timers and regulars alike.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
