Albany’s pizza culture reflects the city’s rich history, diverse neighborhoods, and passionate food lovers.
From old-school Italian pizzerias and New York–style slice shops to wood-fired ovens and creative modern spots, the capital city delivers some of Upstate’s best pies.
Here are the top five pizza places in Albany for 2025, known for taste, tradition, and community spirit.
1. DeFazio’s Pizzeria
Though technically located just across the bridge in Troy, DeFazio’s is well worth the quick trip for what many say is the best pizza in the Capital Region.
Their wood-fired oven produces perfectly blistered crusts, and the menu features everything from classic Margherita and house-made sausage to creative daily specials.
DeFazio’s is family-run, using top-quality ingredients and even local flour, making it a must-visit for diehard pizza fans.
2. Albany Pizza
A true local staple for decades, Albany Pizza offers classic NY-style pies with a thin, foldable crust, tangy-sweet sauce, and plenty of cheese.
Their slices are giant and their whole pies are perfect for sharing, with friendly staff and quick service making it a reliable choice for takeout or a casual meal.
The steady buzz of satisfied regulars is proof of its staying power.
3. The Orchard Tavern
The Orchard is an Albany legend, serving its iconic tavern-style pizza since 1903.
The pies are thin, crisp, and loaded with toppings, drawing crowds for their “Signature Orchard” (sausage, mushroom, onion, and sweet peppers).
This historic spot is a go-to for both families and locals, with a welcoming, old-school vibe and a consistently excellent kitchen.
4. Paesan’s Pizza
One of the Capital District’s biggest local chains, Paesan’s is known for hearty, flavorful pies, loaded subs, and reliable delivery.
Their menu spans NY-style pizza to Sicilian-style squares, plus wings and Italian-American comfort fare.
The “Paesan’s Special” and white pizza are favorites, and locations throughout Albany mean you’re never far from a hot, cheesy slice.
5. Crisan Bakery & Edible Art Gallery
For something a little different, Crisan’s offers artisan personal-sized pizzas with fresh, inventive toppings and perfectly airy crust.
Their European bakery background shines through, and each pie feels lovingly crafted.
The selection rotates often, but you’ll always find vegetarian and seasonal options, plus homemade pastries if you have room for dessert.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
