5 Best Pizza Places in Bloomington, Indiana to Try

Bloomington, Indiana—a lively college town with a passionate food scene—offers pizza lovers a mix of classic pizzerias, inventive new shops, and beloved late-night slice spots.

With influences ranging from traditional Midwestern to artisan Neapolitan, Bloomington’s top pizza joints compete for student loyalty and community acclaim.

Here are the five best pizza places in Bloomington for 2025, each selected for their flavor, consistency, and Hoosier hospitality.

1. Mother Bear’s Pizza

A Bloomington classic since 1973, Mother Bear’s is famed for its thick, chewy crust, generous cheese, and signature sweet-tangy sauce.

The standout topping combos—like the “Divine Swine” (pepperoni, ham, sausage, bacon) or vegetarian “Wildcat”—keep students and locals coming back.

With cozy, campus-adjacent locations and a fun, family-friendly vibe, Mother Bear’s is often named one of the best college-town pizzerias in America.

2. Pizza X

A staple for Indiana University students, Pizza X is all about big, bubbly crusts, endless topping options, and late-night delivery.

Known for their “Cheese X Stix” breadsticks, creative specialty pies, and the legendary “X” sauce, this local chain delivers reliably tasty pies for game night, parties, or midnight cravings.

Affordable prices and a friendly, no-fuss approach seal its status as a campus favorite.

3. King Dough

A newer addition but already a standout, King Dough serves wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizzas with blistered, chewy crusts and fresh, well-crafted ingredients.

Their menu features both traditional and creative pies (try the “Bee Sting”—cup-and-char pepperoni, pickled chiles, hot honey), gluten-free dough, and seasonal toppings.

The hip, welcoming dining room and quality cocktails make it a go-to for foodies and families alike.

4. Aver’s Pizza

Aver’s offers inventive, topping-loaded pies with options ranging from vegan to the ultra-indulgent.

Known for quirky combos (“Cream & Crimson”—alfredo sauce, chicken, bacon, tomatoes) and thick, hand-tossed crusts, Aver’s is a favorite for quick delivery and mix-and-match creativity.

Their “stix” (breadsticks) and specialty sauces are fan favorites, making it a regular choice for group orders and celebrations.

5. Runcible Spoon

While best known as a quirky, homey brunch cafe, Runcible Spoon’s wood-fired pizzas are a hidden gem on its eclectic menu.

Featuring house-made dough, locally sourced ingredients, and unique flavor profiles (like smoked chicken, pesto, and roasted veggies), these artisan pies are as memorable as Runcible’s cozy, literary atmosphere.

Perfect for brunch, dinner, or a relaxed night out away from campus bustle.