Montgomery, Alabama’s pizza scene may fly under the radar, but this historic Southern city delivers plenty of culinary surprises for pizza fans.
From old-school Italian charm to creative, family-owned gems and Southern specialties, these local pizzerias offer a blend of quality, flavor, and hometown hospitality.
Here are the five best pizza places in Montgomery for 2025—perfect for both locals and visitors craving a memorable slice.
1. Tomatino’s Pizza & Bake Shop
A Cloverdale neighborhood staple, Tomatino’s is lauded for fresh, hand-tossed dough, homemade sauces, and a menu full of creative specialty pies.
From the classic Margherita to inventive veggie combos and Southern twists (try the Sweet Home Alabama with smoked chicken and BBQ sauce), every pie is loaded with flavor.
With a cozy, artsy setting and loyal following, Tomatino’s is a must for anyone seeking the best of Montgomery.
2. Midtown Pizza Kitchen
Midtown Pizza Kitchen stands out for its lively atmosphere and broad menu, including hand-crafted thin and thick crust pizzas, calzones, and a broad selection of salads and pastas.
Their specialty pies—like the Spicy Hawaiian or Philly Cheesesteak Pizza—highlight inventive toppings and quality ingredients.
Outdoor seating and a friendly staff round out the upbeat experience.
3. Sa Za Serious Italian Food
Located in the Alley Downtown, Sa Za brings big flavors and bold personality with its gourmet Italian approach.
Pizzas are stone-baked, featuring a cracker thin crust and creative toppings—think imported prosciutto, spicy Italian sausage, or truffle oil.
Sa Za’s house specials, lively ambiance, and full menu of Italian classics make it popular for everything from date nights to family celebrations.
4. D’Road Cafe
Well-known for its Latin and international food, D’Road Cafe has also drawn acclaim for their unique “fusion” pizzas—think Venezuelan-and-Italian-style pies loaded with plantains, shredded beef, and creative cheeses.
The homey, welcoming space and community feel have made D’Road a sleeper pizza hit for adventurous eaters in Montgomery.
5. Little Italy Pizzeria
A downtown favorite for decades, Little Italy Pizzeria is beloved for classic, thin, foldable New York–style pies, saucy subs, and quick counter service.
Their pepperoni pizza, supreme, and veggie pies are all crowd-pleasers, whether you’re grabbing a lunch slice or feeding a family on the go. It’s the perfect casual stop for a reliable bite with real NYC flavor.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
