5 Best Pizza Places in Naperville, Illinois to Try

Naperville’s pizza scene perfectly combines Chicago’s legendary deep-dish influence with a wealth of local favorites, gourmet innovation, and community spirit.

Whether you crave a crispy tavern-cut, a gooey stuffed slice, or modern artisan flair, Naperville’s top pizzerias deliver big on flavor, variety, and hometown pride.

Here are the five best pizza spots in Naperville for 2025—each a reliable go-to for residents, visitors, and pizza obsessives.

1. Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria

A true Chicago icon, Lou Malnati’s has brought its famous deep-dish pies to Naperville, delivering that signature buttery, flaky crust, vine-ripened tomato sauce, and heaps of mozzarella.

Local fans flock here for the “Malnati Chicago Classic” (lean sausage, extra cheese, vine-ripened tomato sauce).

Friendly service, family dine-in, and efficient takeout make Lou’s a no-brainer for both deep-dish cravings and special occasions.

2. Aurelio’s Pizza

A Naperville staple, Aurelio’s is famous for tavern-style thin crust, sweet tomato sauce, and edge-to-edge toppings cut into perfect party squares.

Whether you go classic with sausage and green pepper or opt for a half-sheet supreme, Aurelio’s keeps big groups happy with great value and a nostalgic, family atmosphere that has stood the test of time.

3. Little Pops NY Pizzeria Trattoria

Looking for a true New York slice in the heart of the Midwest?

Little Pops delivers crisp, foldable hand-tossed pies and classic Italian-American comfort food.

Their margherita, white pizzas, and traditional pastas make it a go-to for both transplants and locals, while their bustling, neighborhood feel and brick-oven authenticity set them apart.

4. Angeli’s Pizzeria

A family-run gem, Angeli’s charms with handmade pies, pillowy crusts, and classic Italian comfort.

Guests love their hearty meat-lovers and classic veggie pies, but Angeli’s also turns out beloved pastas, fresh salads, and homemade desserts.

Warm service and consistent quality keep Angeli’s a top choice for takeout, delivery, or casual dine-in.

5. Fat Rosie’s Pizza Co.

The newest addition to Naperville’s pizza elite, Fat Rosie’s has quickly earned fans with its inventive fusion pies—think chorizo & jalapeño, BBQ chicken, and wild seasonal specials.

With a fun, modern space, craft cocktails, and late-night hours, this is where Naperville goes for bold flavors, creative combinations, and a lively vibe.

Gluten-free options and specialty toppings round out the appeal.